Re: Mafia 38- Gotham City

Oxygen wrote:

Tbo should die for this. Torq should be investigated for saying flint is 99% mob. Zarf finished flint and should die too IMO.

Rd was drunk and provided no help at all. Mob?

I kinda agree with this... TBO and Zarf's execution of that vote swap seemed timed and planned. With WC also not doing much to stick up for himself.

Torq on the other hand, Im not sure of.

RD, always plays inactively when playing norm town role, but the timing of his arrival to vote arises suspicion to me. If i was drunk, last thing Id be thinking of is "Shit I should vote in Mafia" when previous rounds he hasnt bothered to vote at all...

"I lie down next to an angel, fall asleep and fly with the demons"
I once prayed to god for some planets, but quickly found out he didnt work that way

Re: Mafia 38- Gotham City

15:33    KT    if you do i will lynch you!
15:34    Poley    haha
15:34    Poley    so it goes like this...
15:34    Poley    You kill ER
15:34    Poley    and frame me for it, ey?
15:35    KT    nope im gonna try and help ER

There you have it folks, the ringleader has called the shots.

When its revealed that if ER dies tonight and Im lynched tomorrow and Im town, you will have something to run on wink

Very vocal of KT for once me thinks yikes

"I lie down next to an angel, fall asleep and fly with the demons"
I once prayed to god for some planets, but quickly found out he didnt work that way

Re: Mafia 38- Gotham City

*sigh*

C+P didnt fully work... Spam away!!

15:33    KT    you are full blooded mobster im sure X( i bet you kill ER tonight too
15:33    KT    if you do i will lynch you!

"I lie down next to an angel, fall asleep and fly with the demons"
I once prayed to god for some planets, but quickly found out he didnt work that way

Re: Mafia 38- Gotham City

This looks pretty bad for you Poley as ER was trying to save Flint.. catwoman.

~~Lemming of leather and lollipops~~

Right, so what are we waiting for?  Can we get this going?  Any other feedback?

Re: Mafia 38- Gotham City

KT, Im willing to die for a cause big_smile

I have no control on ER dying during night phase. If it so happens that it does, and ppl suspect me for it, Im all happy to be lynched, and found out that Im town, so that the one making the threats is bought into the spot light, aka, yourself! wink

"I lie down next to an angel, fall asleep and fly with the demons"
I once prayed to god for some planets, but quickly found out he didnt work that way

Re: Mafia 38- Gotham City

Okay, so now a hell of a lot has gone on.

Was TBO trying to get two people killed?

Re: Mafia 38- Gotham City

Dude I honestly was drunk tongue. I try to put in an effort for once and still make the vote as i (miraculously) get home just in time to get my vote in... not like i had planned it that way, but meh!

Maar doodslaan deed hij niet, want tussen droom en daad,
Staan wetten in de weg en praktische bezwaren,
En ook weemoedigheid, die niemand kan verklaren,
En die des avonds komt, wanneer men slapen gaat.

Re: Mafia 38- Gotham City

Youre vote was late, but nevermind, the damage has been done now tongue

"I lie down next to an angel, fall asleep and fly with the demons"
I once prayed to god for some planets, but quickly found out he didnt work that way

Re: Mafia 38- Gotham City

Are cats not supposed to have 9 lives? X(

*goes away with those last words*

Everything bad in the economy is now Obama's fault. Every job lost, all the debt, all the lost retirement funds. All Obama. Are you happy now? We all get to blame Obama!
Kemp currently not being responded to until he makes CONCISE posts.
Avogardo and Noir ignored by me for life so people know why I do not respond to them. (Informational)

Re: Mafia 38- Gotham City

1. TBO doing his vote switch was intentional to make a tie and see 2 people go home. thats either mobbish or incredibly dumb. i am willing to lynch for either of those reasons.

2. While I am not sure what role Zarf is, there were a few of us chatting in #mafia and the decision came about to NOT vote flint and do WC instead. When Zarf seen the vote by TBO to tie it he quickly shifted and went flint. Could it be that it was planned? sure...I don't have a full opinion on that yet.

3. ER was pushing hard to save flint. So don't be surprised if he dies tonight. Just sayin doc...get on it?

4. Torq was pushing very hard to kill flint. Could it be that he knew something? Or did he have trust issues from the get-go cause of flint's history? cops...that should be you!

If ER dies tonight, then TBO should probably be an easy first lynch.

Solis - #7872

Re: Mafia 38- Gotham City

"1. TBO doing his vote switch was intentional to make a tie and see 2 people go home. thats either mobbish or incredibly dumb. i am willing to lynch for either of those reasons.

Very, very bad.  The idea is to expose voting patterns.  Getting two people killed as a result, is very anti-town behaviour.  He may not be mob, we all know TBO could be  the other option!

"2. While I am not sure what role Zarf is, there were a few of us chatting in #mafia and the decision came about to NOT vote flint and do WC instead. When Zarf seen the vote by TBO to tie it he quickly shifted and went flint. Could it be that it was planned? sure...I don't have a full opinion on that yet."

Zarfs smarter than he lets on, is my view.  Not sure with the history of this, since I was away for the tie.


"3. ER was pushing hard to save flint. So don't be surprised if he dies tonight. Just sayin doc...get on it?"

Pushing hard to save flint, or pushing hard to kill WC?  Given he wanted others to vote WC, and he even wanted WC to die before.  ER was trying to not make a tie, he was trying to get someoene to switch at end of phase.  Either way, can't really get a read on ER atm.


"4. Torq was pushing very hard to kill flint. Could it be that he knew something? Or did he have trust issues from the get-go cause of flint's history? cops...that should be you!"

I wasn't pushing at all, let alone "very hard".  In forum I pointed out why his behaviour was odd and he didn't have any responses to my questions, refer:  http://www.imperialconflict.com/forum/viewtopic.php?pid=1629819#p1629819 .  Yea, he might have been away or whatever at the time, but he's the one who wrote all that in the first place.  If anything, I put up the most arguments for someone. Granted, it was wrong - but noone came in and said "yea, torq is right" or "we agree with torq".  Yet for some reason, we find Flint lynched.


"If ER dies tonight, then TBO should probably be an easy first lynch."

Try to stay away from this thinking.  A lot can happen overnight - and we need to relook at what happens.  Because, if TBO is not mob, mob can easily use such arguments and what not, to end up getting a free mislynch.

Re: Mafia 38- Gotham City

Poley wrote:
{Sexy}EvilRunt wrote:

and town does what town does best... Hurt itself

You did town no favours ER, pushing for someone to get lynched is mobbish no matter the the outcome of the other being lynched...

I disagree with your view here.  Pushing for someone to get lynched (or what I always say, express their opinion) is a great way to reveal what's going on.  Yes, it worked out badly in this case, but we know a hell of a lot more now than we would ahve with people just randomly voting with 1 vote and then someone dying with only 2 votes on them.  That's completely anti-town behaviour.  It's just a pity that the actual townies we have in IC mafia, don't realise this.

Re: Mafia 38- Gotham City

Ok, I stand corrected on you pushing hard. It just seemed like a big blow up between you and flint. I guess it is just a matter of how you read the situation and as I was not there for it I get all the back end stuff.

Obviously whatever happens tonight is going to be a huge difference maker on the decisions made tomorrow. I am clearly looking at the perspective of what happened during the lynch.

Its really hard for me to make a read right now on what the overall schemes were for each player involved. But I have a feeling the next lynch is going to reveal a LOT of info.

Solis - #7872

Re: Mafia 38- Gotham City

Well, Arby's set this game up to have a lot of actions at night.

So, lol, lets see what happens.

Re: Mafia 38- Gotham City

Torqez wrote:
Poley wrote:
{Sexy}EvilRunt wrote:

and town does what town does best... Hurt itself

You did town no favours ER, pushing for someone to get lynched is mobbish no matter the the outcome of the other being lynched...

I disagree with your view here.  Pushing for someone to get lynched (or what I always say, express their opinion) is a great way to reveal what's going on.  Yes, it worked out badly in this case, but we know a hell of a lot more now than we would ahve with people just randomly voting with 1 vote and then someone dying with only 2 votes on them.  That's completely anti-town behaviour.  It's just a pity that the actual townies we have in IC mafia, don't realise this.

huh? First day lynch is always COMPLETELY random from 95% of players, unless someone is stupid enough to spill their role, or a cop investigates someone night 1 and confides in them day 1 (which is still incredibly risky).

What do we know more from ppls votes by what ER did, if anything he has placed himself in a compromising position? There is close to bugger all that can be figured out from the way ppl vote on day 1. I dont understand how you think ppl should vote day 1? You do realise that not everyone that votes is town, right? tongue

Anyhow, I dont mean to argue with a bunch of you guys, since I think the majority of us in here arguing are actually town.

Maybe we should focus our energies on outing those quiet ones!

"I lie down next to an angel, fall asleep and fly with the demons"
I once prayed to god for some planets, but quickly found out he didnt work that way

Re: Mafia 38- Gotham City

Wooohooo i LOVE outing people!

Hydro, last round i thought id be smarter, and every nightphase I was more confused so for now I'll have to reread all these walls of text and see if anything actually worthwhile can be logically derived from it. Excited for nightnight phase ending as always!

Re: Mafia 38- Gotham City

Poley wrote:

There is close to bugger all that can be figured out from the way ppl vote on day 1.

Here is where your thinking is wrong.  It may not be evident immediately, but it can help later on as the game progresses.

Also, there's always the chance something comes up once somoene is pressured and asked for reasoning on stuff (e.g. Why ddi flint post what he did?  Why did he not answer my questions?  Why did ER tie the votes? Why did TBO want to kill two people? etc).

Another example is last game. Look at first day voting, it helped us uncover Arby (mob) trying to kill Flint.  Even Nolio admitted that he was doing the same thing and that was also a mistake (though noone pinned him as mob for it, except flint (but that doesn't count)).

Re: Mafia 38- Gotham City

Poley, what Torq means is that the power the mob has is co-ordination, whilst town has numbers. It means everyone spreading their vote only helps the mob, as they can spread as well and then cherry pick the lynch target without being too suspicious. However co-ordinated townies can counter this by talking as much as possible and getting some information flowing, then looking to pick up inconsistancies, either with voting or comments. This may give hints to true mob... So he isn't saying that the votes count, more the talking... and true townies should be talking as much as possible...

"Sticks and stones may break my bones, but i am Jesus"
"Nothing is worse than a fully prepared fool"

Re: Mafia 38- Gotham City

Also Torq beat me too it X(

"Sticks and stones may break my bones, but i am Jesus"
"Nothing is worse than a fully prepared fool"

145 (edited by Undeath 21-Feb-2013 15:58:16)

Re: Mafia 38- Gotham City

To Clarify:

Nolio and Risingdown missed first round of voting.  RD's did not vote in the initial vote phase, therefore his vote during the extension is not counted.  If you miss 2 votes in the game, you will be killed off immediately.

<KT|Away> I am the Trump of IC

Re: Mafia 38- Gotham City

And to top it off even more, I know from the 2 previous games I played that if I do not get involved this game gets boring as a townie. So I would like to contribute in any way I can by simply chatting and trying to dissect things to help us out. Never know, might just get lucky and land a mobbie myself.

But even if I don't, I know there are some really good players who will eventually do it.

Solis - #7872

Re: Mafia 38- Gotham City

> Freezy wrote:

> I have 14 planets in Tri so its #14.....Poley!

@ Undeath: Do you not see my posts?! I allready quoted once. I did not miss my vote!!!!

Some cause happiness wherever they go; others whenever they go.
~Oscar Wilde~

Re: Mafia 38- Gotham City

Glad to hear that Hydro. Townies speculating and asking questions is a big part of this game - it's also one of the best parts. If every townie gets involved like that more information would surface and it would make the "metagame" (Read: Player interaction) a lot more fun for everyone. I'm pretty sure that after this last lynch there will be lots of activity in the chat tonight. And I won't miss it!

Re: Mafia 38- Gotham City

Phase over story to follow

Modestus Experitus

Arby: A very strict mod, reminds me of a fat redneck who drives a truck around all day with a beer in one hand. I hated this guy at the start, however, I played a round in PW with him where he went as an anonymous player. Our fam got smashed up and everyone pretty much left. Arby stayed around and helped out the remaining family. At the end of the round he revealed himself.... My views on him have changed since. Your a good guy.....

Re: Mafia 38- Gotham City

YEah Freezy voted last lynching! So don't penalise him for it!

Hurry with the story! I thought i was gonna be late for it lol

Miss Che Vias-Sprite
Yehes ha sowena whath dhewgh why ha 'gas henath

Be Troll Aware!