1 (edited by Justinian I 15-Oct-2008 23:15:45)

Topic: US should militarily intervene in South America

Hugo Chavez has started quite a stir in South America. He has earned support from the other powers on the continent such as Argentina, Brazil, and Chile. Aside from the fact that the US has lost control of oil resources in Venezuela, the powers in the regions have begun to cooperate and seek out international support from other core powers around the globe such as China and Russia. The resulting outcome in South America is,

1. Indirect military support from Russia/China
2. Financial support from R/C
3. SA snubbing at the US, a good example is Argentina
4. China buying the land around the Panama Canal
5. The US losing its power and influence in South America

In summary, these events will be detrimental to the US unless we stop toying with the middle east and address real problems, like the ones in our back yard. Not only will it harm the US, but it will realign the global balance of power in a very not so cool way. The US must act. The US must

1. Eliminate Hugo Chavez and return private ownership of Venezuela's oil reserves.
2. Get hawkish with China and Russia, threatening them with war if they don't stop (of course only a ceremonious gesture; they'll back down).
3. Display our naval power in the pacific.
4. Beat up a few South American countries a little, and then offer peace on condition they agree to some free-market concessions and allow the US to build military bases in their countries.
5. Retake the panama canal.

In other areas of the world, the US should pursue a foreign policy of detente and strive to maintain a balance of power rather than run around guided by misguided moral ideals like spreading democracy everywhere.

2 (edited by Gwynedd 16-Oct-2008 09:41:52)

Re: US should militarily intervene in South America

I think the USA should Leave South America alone to run their own affairs how they see fit.

In other words "[The fmods owned me before I even knew it!] off "

Re: US should militarily intervene in South America

Very misguided.

Re: US should militarily intervene in South America

You don

The inmates are running the asylum

5 (edited by Selur Ku 15-Oct-2008 23:26:02)

Re: US should militarily intervene in South America

Posts like justinians,  make the rest of the world hope to see America get a kicking

the unbelievable arrogance.

none of yr fing business how venezuela/chile/agentina/bolivia or any other country want to run their affairs,

i personally would like to see a S AMerican joint army invade USA to eliminate twats like justinian

Re: US should militarily intervene in South America

I think you're just pissed that socialism is working so well.



This isn't the cold war.  Our own government is making socialist moves just to ensure the survival of our economy.

He who stands atop the highest pyramid of skulls can see the furthest

7 (edited by Justinian I 15-Oct-2008 23:28:29)

Re: US should militarily intervene in South America

esa,

A balance of power means that the US

1. Does not try to monopolize power and influence in the Middle East and Eastern Europe.
2. The US eases tensions with Russia with respect to its peripheral zone.
3. The US withdraws most of its troops in Iraq.

When those conditions are satisfied, we can crush the South Americans and have the military force to do it as well as the international apathy.

Selur,

You're just ignorant of realpolitik. Go away. You're a misguided moral idealist, no better than Bush.

8 (edited by Selur Ku 15-Oct-2008 23:43:02)

Re: US should militarily intervene in South America

No im  completely aware of realpolitik

Im well aware that the USA, has murdered/ propped up dictators/ organised coups and generally backed whichever side suits USA business interests for the last 50-60 years or more.

Doesnt mean I support it

you "go away" with your idiot wishlist

Re: US should militarily intervene in South America

But thats not going to happen cos McCain is a russian hater and Obama

The inmates are running the asylum

10 (edited by Justinian I 15-Oct-2008 23:53:34)

Re: US should militarily intervene in South America

Selur,

And that's the way the world has worked for the past, uh, since the beginning of civilization?

The way I see it, you can waste your life trying to advance moral causes. Another thing you can do is embrace reality and profit from it.

Nonetheless, it's in much of the world's best interest if the US remains a major power in the world, rather than someone else filling the power vacuum like Russia, China or whoever else. It's also essential to American power to maintain its political grip on South America. You can argue it's wrong to do so, but the other powers in the world aren't going to change their ways either.

The problem with the US is that Bush is acting like Wilhelm II. In pursuit of moral ideals and short-sighted goals, he is creating tension to the balance of power. Though unlike Wilhelm II who caused an ugly arms race, Bush got us entangled in a real nasty proxy war. The US needs someone more strategically minded to preserve the balance of power. It's essential to world peace and prosperity.

esa,

Sometimes I wonder if Obama is just saying that to gather support, but the US has major leadership problems I agree. Nonetheless, we must do what what I said and more.

You're right the Iraq war has cost us trillions, and it's immense cost and no strategic value is every reason we should exit asap.

Re: US should militarily intervene in South America

http://www.cnbc.com/id/27121970

outrageous!

The inmates are running the asylum

Re: US should militarily intervene in South America

Very

Re: US should militarily intervene in South America

is it any of YOUR business whether we mind our own business?

so whose business is that?

socialism justifies dictatorship?  Teachers forced to swear allegiance to Chavez?? party paramilitary murdering protestors?

The core joke of Hitchhiker's Guide to the Galaxy is that of course no civilization would develop personal computers with instant remote database recovery, and then waste this technology to find good drinks.
Steve Jobs has ruined this joke.

Re: US should militarily intervene in South America

to say how S. Americans run their countries is there own business and we should stay out is a very outdated view that has caused many problems. If history has taught us anything its that how other countries run their governments is our business.

Re: US should militarily intervene in South America

as far as i know chavez was voted in by his own people. there is no reason what so ever for USA to interfere.
noone is breaking any international laws by any of the things you mentioned, USA would by attacking.

besides, china is holding USA by the testicles atm, they need to twist a little and USA will be in a lot of pain. If china withdraws all it's money from the USA, they will be bankrupt before the end of the day.

NEE NAW NEE NAW

Primo

Re: US should militarily intervene in South America

avogadro wrote:

to say how S. Americans run their countries is there own business and we should stay out is a very outdated view that has caused many problems. If history has taught us anything its that how other countries run their governments is our business.

Agreed.



Should the US intervene? Nope. For the reasons Primo mentioned.

Sex without the e is still SX!

17 (edited by Selur Ku 16-Oct-2008 08:54:53)

Re: US should militarily intervene in South America

> The_Yell wrote:

> is it any of YOUR business whether we mind our own business?

so whose business is that?

socialism justifies dictatorship?  Teachers forced to swear allegiance to Chavez?? party paramilitary murdering protestors?


Yes it is my business to Comment , since this is a politics forum. Its still in no way Americas business to murder, overthrow elected governments or Tell south American people what governmnet they should have.

I know you are not stupid, so you are being deliberately deceitful here when you play the Dictatorship = bad card. You know as well as I do that USA are quite happy to support dictators if it suits American interests. Even going as far as overthrowing democratically elected governments to replace them with military dictatorships when it suits Amercian business interests.

Chavez was democratically elected. get over it.

18 (edited by Raif 16-Oct-2008 09:01:37)

Re: US should militarily intervene in South America

primo - besides, china is holding USA by the testicles atm, they need to twist a little and USA will be in a lot of pain. If china withdraws all it's money from the USA, they will be bankrupt before the end of the day.

-------------

wouldnt this be the last thing that china would want to do? this would create and even worse financial crisis than now and no-one would be buying any chinese manufactured goods

also it would leave both of the US' testicles firmly in the sweaty palm of Japan, another thing i would think China wouldnt be happy with.

--------

on the topic of chavez getting voted in, didnt he get in because he promised to confiscate land off the rich and give it to poor farmers? which hasnt been done

also the US is one signature away from being a police state tongue

Hsin Shee Lahn - Raif - Winton Rufer - Superman - Winterfell - Once - Raif Heart Kill - Ted Bundy - Valiant - Blackhail - antEhelp

Re: US should militarily intervene in South America

raif, if USA threatens china with war, i don't think china will just back down like that. they are stronger than the  USA in any aspect atm, why would they back down

NEE NAW NEE NAW

Primo

Re: US should militarily intervene in South America

Why do people constantly assume Americans want to war with China?

Brother Simon, Keeper of Ages, Defender of Faith.
~ ☭ Fokker

Re: US should militarily intervene in South America

Justinian I wrote:

2. Get hawkish with China and Russia, threatening them with war if they don't stop (of course only a ceremonious gesture; they'll back down).

Cause that's what was stated in the first post

NEE NAW NEE NAW

Primo

Re: US should militarily intervene in South America

First post simply sounds like Hitler a lil.. just short time before he ordered to invade russia. pure megalomania.

Re: US should militarily intervene in South America

why threaten china when they can equip taiwan and make taiwan-china fight themselves.

i love you all!

Re: US should militarily intervene in South America

Because the Taiwanese have caught on and aren't so eager to play the part of the U.S's proxy battleground anymore.

25 (edited by CanadianTire 16-Oct-2008 12:10:35)

Re: US should militarily intervene in South America

Justian, you sound like a child whose neighbour ran over your new puppy and now your out to extract revenge by offering him lemonade you've peed in. Grow up before you and BW become indistinguishable.

The last thing the world needs with this current market crisis is Bush showing how big his country's penis is, one last time before he leaves office for good.

And how will you find support for such a thing? Bring 10 year old reports to the UN that Chavez has nukes that could blow up Mars or some other such nonsense? Sorry, but you've done that already. The world won't be duped again.

"In a world of global deceit, telling the truth is a revolutionary act." George Orwell