Talked to Alundra on IRC and this is the log:
[23:01] <Alundra> keerb
[23:01] <Keerb> Alundra
[23:01] <Alundra> im making it a point of telling x amount of people just incase i get killed,one of the peeps has to be town lol
[23:02] <Alundra> arby3 is sticking up for wiwi. high chance he is mob
[23:03] <Alundra> and hydrop openly admitted he was mob. i think in an attempt to get cop to investigate him . meaning he will be mob who shows up as town
Not really sure what course of action should be taken. As we start with nightphase cop will need to do investigations, either for someone to ally with or to confirm some of the theories going around.
The Alundra/Wiwi/Arby/Hydro case should be possible to solve with lynching a key player in here and see if Alundra's theory holds true while cop investigates someone else.
You could also investigate Alundra, Wiwi or Arby to see if the information holds true.
In any case it seems both lynching and investigating more than one of these players will be a waste of an investigation/lynch which could possibly be spent better elsewhere. And investigating a townie/pro town role is a lot less worse than managing to lynch one by bad luck.
It's easier to organize a lynch on one of the names already out in the open without the cop having to show his/hers face yet, so I think we should go for a lynch of one of the mentioned players and the cop should investigate some of the more quiet players for now.
You're in an interesting dilemma here cop - make the most of it!