Thank you Templare for taking the time and effort to answer to my post to such an extent. I was not able to respond earlier since I had some real-life tasks. I will comment on each point as you did with and put forth the same time and effort you did.
"Render signed the NAP because his family faced extinction at the beginning of round, it was either NAP or being killed off, of course he did what's in the best interest of his family by NAPing, please be careful of your use of the word "forced". He did indeed gain shares through the war with 15 and shares with 06/09."
The use of the word "forced" was accurate and I have nothing to add to the rest of your comment.
"08 cancelled on 09, then 10 ticks later 06 cancelled on 08 for the best interest of their alliance. If Render wanted a honorable war, he would have given the planets back and fought 09 for the first 10 hours. He had every intention to use the shares he acquired as leverage in order to defeat a "seemingly strong" family in 09 which lost two of their main attackers within the last few days. His obliteration was inevitable, and he chose to even the odds by performing an illegal action by agreement."
I fail to see how losing "two of their main attackers within the last few days" is relavant to this case. Atm Render is the only real active attacker and correct me if I am wrong, 09 has 2 active attackers. In your comment, you say that render "uses the shares he acquired as leverage in order to defeat a "seemingly strong" family in 09", but is this not what 09/06 wanted to do with the share's they had with Render? Is this not what EVERY family in war does when their nap expires and they go to war? Yes they are core violations but other than that I fail to see how that is relavant.
"His obliteration was inevitable, and he chose to even the odds by performing an illegal action by agreement." The thing is Templare, his obliteration was evitable. The only way was by performing an illegal action by agreement. If he had stayed honorable as many suggested then his pcount would have definetly not be this high and he would have been killed after the first 2 days. As we speak Render is fighting you, serenity, john conner, (mizzle?), killas, and HJ all alone, I would say he's doing quitte well.
"Basically he pursued dishonor in order to defend his family, that's fair, as long as he admits it. Since you're going to share the "full" story, I'll add a little bit so the rest of Pinwheel is better informed. According to key players in both 08/05, 08 and 05 have recently joined alliance and had been plotting this war for a while. Both family are fully aware of the advantages 08 has on 06/09, and it is the goal of 05 to use their recently acquired allies to both deny victory to 06/09 and compensating themselves for infrawhoring all round.
Since the NAP break performed by Render, 05 alliance has aided over 400mil gc and numbers of million of iron and endu to 08 alliance, in exchange that 08 will give majority of the planets they captured to 05. Because 05 still has PNAP with 06/09, they will be able to hold onto those captures in order to secure their victory in size. When informed that 06 will most likely exceed planet size after the war with 08, members of 05 immediately went forth to plan this maneuver. This plan has backfired to a certain extent, because not only was 08 not able to capture planets to pass to 05, they have lost over 500 planets themselves, despite having the NAP break advantage (all of my shares were cleared). So far, many of the retake planets have been passed to 05.."
"When informed that 06 will most likely exceed planet size after the war with 08, members of 05 immediately went forth to plan this maneuver. "
Not sure where you got that information from, but it is incorrect. The plan was made before 06 cancelled nap with 08. Yes, the plan has back-fired to a certain extent but we are still first in size so it's not a complete failure.
"I must admit that this is not illegal and even clever in the part of 05, but objectively speaking, this would solidify the idea that 05 has failed to done anything significant (you read it right, I said it) this round while coasting to size win (and possibly NW win), while 06/09 managed to beat families that were worth while (including the previously top alliance, who similarly performed a NAP break in order to gain advantage), and beat them badly."
This is not objective at all on the contrary it proves the opposite, that we have influence on PW eventhough we pnapped everyone 
Or did you want us to do something "significant" and break pnap? Because that is the only other thing we can do.
Also, your family managed to beat nobody since everybody deleted before the war started, don't give yourself credit where you do not deserve it. One of the family was at war before with 08 as well.
"I told my alliance to not run into Uni News and run our mouths about all the controversy surrounding the war because we have decided to play with the cards that have been dealt, but since Ariana decided to post his subjective opinion above, I decided it was time for me to reveal all relevant information"
What exactly are you implying with "since Ariana decided to post his subjective opinion above"? I hope you are not implying that your opinion is objective, as it is far from being objective! Nobody's opinion is objective if it come's from 06/09/05/08 so I fail to see the point in that as well. Thank you for revealing that relevant information!
Ariana
