Re: Why are poor people poor?

I love this focus on 'greed' as the reason your ass is poor. And scarcity of resources, as if nations utilize half of their national resources. Most of the nations we get our resources from are poor--we pay them to ruin their environments and sell us cheap labor. Exploitation ftw. And there are many countries rich off oil. The point is resources are only 1 factor, and many nations are doing well w/o a disproportionate supply. So maybe you should look further.

As for greed: Dumbest idea in this entire thread. Like somehow when someone earns millions he's inherently stealing it from you. Dream on.

[I wish I could obey forum rules]

Re: Why are poor people poor?

40,000 pounds of weight.  1200 miles average distance. Then fuel costs.

7 miles per gallon.  $2.25 average for gallon.

These are good averages for you to use.

Everything bad in the economy is now Obama's fault. Every job lost, all the debt, all the lost retirement funds. All Obama. Are you happy now? We all get to blame Obama!
Kemp currently not being responded to until he makes CONCISE posts.
Avogardo and Noir ignored by me for life so people know why I do not respond to them. (Informational)

Re: Why are poor people poor?

Flint, that doesn't actually answer his point.  Xeno is saying that if, instead of buying food, you were to simply grow your own food, you wouldn't need to pay that cost of transportation at all.  Thus, no matter how cheap it is, it's more expensive than nothing.


How to answer this?  Compare it to:
A: The cost of creating agriculture in regions that can't currently support farmland.
B: Ask how efficient current farmland would be if the interdependence didn't exist to support industrial agriculture.


Xeno, I've got a separate, giant post coming up in relation to what you said to me.

Make Eyes Great Again!

The Great Eye is watching you... when there's nothing good on TV...

Re: Why are poor people poor?

Flint: it is cheap to transport, but I agree with Xeno (for a change, and not because he is an idiot) it is still 'expensive' to buy, even if said expense is justified by the 'cost' of producing, suppliying and distributing said food.

All resources are scarce, for if they were not then we would all have said resource and the need for money and wealth would be negated, and thus there would be no rich and no poor. this is not to say that the rich are stealing from the poor, but that because there is greed and scarcity of resources this means that there will not be a equal distribution of said resources, and those that have more will be 'rich' and those that have less will be 'poor.' Thr problem is with the current model of distribution there are billions which live barely on the edge (or completly underneath) the poverty line, a theortical concept upon which it is the bare minimum one requires to survive.

of course everyone here is 'wealthy' in a way and most are young and can't see beyond their own idioticy to that which is the real world...

"Sticks and stones may break my bones, but i am Jesus"
"Nothing is worse than a fully prepared fool"

Re: Why are poor people poor?

Define "expensive."

Make Eyes Great Again!

The Great Eye is watching you... when there's nothing good on TV...

Re: Why are poor people poor?

in terms of money spent by the individual.  Seeds are cheaper than the foodstuf and will produce more crop than i will eat. thus is 'cheaper' than buying the end product. There are other factors involved which even out the sides of the ledger, but in terms of money and the indivudual (the only way to talk with right wing idiots) the growing yourself option is 'cheaper' than the buying the end product option.

"Sticks and stones may break my bones, but i am Jesus"
"Nothing is worse than a fully prepared fool"

57 (edited by Zarf BeebleBrix 05-Apr-2010 22:19:29)

Re: Why are poor people poor?

Does that consider environmental factors?  I live in Las Vegas, in the middle of a desert.  Is it cheaper for me to build a greenhouse to grow food so that I'm not trying to grow potatoes in 100 degree summers and cold, dry winters, and attempting to increase my water rights for my greenhouse, or to just go to the store and buy something?


Or how about the loss of specialization of labor?  Look, a lawyer can make $500 an hour doing lawyer work.  No matter how good that lawyer was at farming, it would be nearly impossible for him to produce an equivalent of $500 per hour working in his personal farm.  Wouldn't it be cheaper for that lawyer to spend an hour filing paperwork, then go to the grocery store, as opposed to producing even $499 in food in that hour (which is an EXTREMELY high value for food produced by a single farmer... unless he eats nothing but cocaine)?



And before you say it, yes.  The specialization of labor argument applies to people outside of high-paid professionals.  To begin farming, a person would have to take the time learning a new skill (consequently sacrificing potential time to accrue money through work), and unless that person is a farmer by profession, it's likely they won't be as good at the work as a normal farmer.  Now it would require a larger spreadsheet and some empirical examples to extrapolate the details, but by the land being used by inefficient workers to farm, resources (and thus potential supply of resources on the market) are wasted, reducing efficiency of production.

Make Eyes Great Again!

The Great Eye is watching you... when there's nothing good on TV...

Re: Why are poor people poor?

Hence why I classed my 'expensive' in terms of moeny and not the oppotunity cost of the action. yes it is 'cheaper' in some cases to buy rather than farm, but that requires outside factors to be introduced, and said factors can easily work in the opposite direction, which are obviously factors in rural areas where said farming occurs. I did say that the price is a reflection of the cost of producing the foodstuf, which also takes into account oppotunity costs. Obviously this is how the price point is determined, if it was higher than more people would take on the cost and time to grow their own food, if it was lower less people would take up farming.

"Sticks and stones may break my bones, but i am Jesus"
"Nothing is worse than a fully prepared fool"

59 (edited by Zarf BeebleBrix 05-Apr-2010 22:46:01)

Re: Why are poor people poor?

Then if anything, you're in agreement with Flint and myself.  Your model allows opportunity cost and comparative advantage (that some regions are better at growing crops than others) to take effect, which both Flint and myself would agree exist (Remember, for it to be cheaper to buy crops than to produce, there must be another region in the world where it's cheaper to grow crops than to buy... our models assume that environmental factors work both ways).


In fact, if anything, that's the core of our argument: because in some regions, environmental factors create favorable conditions for growing food, while other regions inhibit said growth, it is necessary and desirable for those regions which would be inefficient in growing food to instead focus on their core competencies and abandon the desire to grow food anyway.

The costs that xeno cites of transporting goods from farm to supermarket are probably overwhelmed by the cost of creating new agricultural infrastructures in regions where the planet is environmentally hostile to the growth of said crops.

Plus, even if there are one or two crops that could be grown on all land, it wouldn't help.  Remember, humans need balanced diets, requiring a multitude of crops grown.  If everyone lives off their own farms, and some farmland is only good for a couple crops, the result is still one of various health problems (hehe, his economic model causes massive scurvey outbreaks) tongue.

Remember, xeno's argument is extremely different: he is claiming that, on all levels, it is more desirable to grow food on your own than to buy it from others.  Unlike you and me, his model would require us to remove comparative advantage models, which have proven successful in gauging growth for centuries.

Claiming you're in agreement with xeno is a massive distortion of your representation of economic models.


Hence, why I asked you to define "expensive."  smile

Make Eyes Great Again!

The Great Eye is watching you... when there's nothing good on TV...

Re: Why are poor people poor?

I am probably more in agreement in regards to our thoughts on how it all works, however (at least with flint) I seem to be coming to different conclusions.

Flint uses this model to argue that scarcity of resources are not a prime factor in poverty and sticks with his deluded right-wing concept that poor people are inherantly lazy and that they are bleeding the system dry. My thought is that despite the fact we are probably doing the best with the systems that we are using the prime factor to which causes poverty is the inherant greed of humans and the scarcity of resources coupled with this greed creates the imbalance between rich and poor, in fact the whole concept is only created because of these factors. laziness does come into effect as a secondary factor, especially in inherantly rich areas. My counter-argument therefore is that since we are mostly rich, given the pure fact we are debating this concept on a forum for an internet browser based game (hardly an essential for spending money on,) that the main factor we see in our everyday life that seperates poor from rich is what some people intrepret as laziness. This however is not a global factor as it is only a factor in rich countries, and even then will be a minor factor, that gets high visability and thus gets to be a blanket reason for poverty.

"Sticks and stones may break my bones, but i am Jesus"
"Nothing is worse than a fully prepared fool"

61 (edited by Zarf BeebleBrix 05-Apr-2010 23:09:51)

Re: Why are poor people poor?

Fair enough, then.  Thought you were challenging the great David Ricardo.  tongue

Make Eyes Great Again!

The Great Eye is watching you... when there's nothing good on TV...

Re: Why are poor people poor?

Oh I wouldn't do that!

"Sticks and stones may break my bones, but i am Jesus"
"Nothing is worse than a fully prepared fool"

Re: Why are poor people poor?

> Einstein wrote:

> A poor person in the United States for instance, has a Cell Phone on average, a big screen television, a car, and fancy shoes.



yikes

C4|DM
DarkMason
I just told my pilot: "Land it in tha BACK YARD!"
Skee-Skee-SPLAT!!!

Re: Why are poor people poor?

What flint means is that his distorted view of the poor in the States is that they own these things, mostly because if the poor live like that then that justifies his greedy selfish world view...

"Sticks and stones may break my bones, but i am Jesus"
"Nothing is worse than a fully prepared fool"

Re: Why are poor people poor?

Now I can reply.... darn Zarf for taking much of the wind from my sails...

First aand foremost scarcity is relative, and most scarcity is due to unwillingness to get the product or... worse... it is regulated to prevent the product from being as available as desired.

Some products are scarce, like shrimp, lobster, kobe beef, and the likes.

Some are not, like sand (glass can be made from it), wood, salt water, wheat, rice, and for sure... oxygen.

Your efforts define a broad base for purposes of your philosophy, and they are not valid.

The three necessities of life; food, water, shelter.

There is no other needs for life, just bonuses. I am quite sure Justinian will even agree.

Now why should we dictate food types? Prisoners throughout history have lived on bread and water.

No... instead we have a natural, and desirable supply and demand. Just like the whole population cannot go to Disneyland in the same week, is just like that we cannot all enjoy kobe steak at once.

There is no limit on power available, except regulations. There is enough food for everyone except those who have leaders who steal their food. There would be jobs for all except over-taxation, over-regulation and lack of laws being enforced (criminal laws).

The very scarcities you bring up would not exist if laws got out of the way of the able and if no one demanded help when they are capable.




Specialization is important also. China once decided to go your route as much as was possible.

They printed a guide on making silverware from a home forge. They expected all Chinese to make their own.

It was a disaster. Most of the silverware was not identifiable as such and the costs to be self efficient out weighed the efficiencies of mass production.

I may know the principles of making an air plane, have the schematics for it, but will you trust me to test fly it over your house?

Flight after all is a commodity, why should I be denied it under your broad assumption?


I could go on, but I want to see if you respond fully to my post first, and because texting sucks with big thumbs that are not used to it.

Everything bad in the economy is now Obama's fault. Every job lost, all the debt, all the lost retirement funds. All Obama. Are you happy now? We all get to blame Obama!
Kemp currently not being responded to until he makes CONCISE posts.
Avogardo and Noir ignored by me for life so people know why I do not respond to them. (Informational)

66 (edited by You_Fool 06-Apr-2010 22:19:45)

Re: Why are poor people poor?

[appologies to flint and Zarf]


>>The three necessities of life; food, water, shelter. <<

yes these are the main necessities, and to ensure that a high standard of life is maintained these need to be of good or better quality. A balanced diet is needed, which requires multiple different nutrients, vitamins, etc... Water requires to be clean and shelter needs to be of good construction to withstand the climate involved. Then one moves onto secondary 'needs' which are needed in the society one lives in. In rural africa the 3 basic needs would probably be sufficient, in urban america these would not be.

>>First aand foremost scarcity is relative, and most scarcity is due to unwillingness to get the product or... worse... it is regulated to prevent the product from being as available as desired.

Some products are scarce, like shrimp, lobster, kobe beef, and the likes.

Some are not, like sand (glass can be made from it), wood, salt water, wheat, rice, and for sure... oxygen. <<

You are wrong in the conclusion of this, all resources are scarce, though as you say to different degrees. Some are regulated to be more scarce than they really are, though normally by companies/industry not government policy as you seem to be implying, though thats not to say that government regulation doesn't exisit, jsut look at the US's trade barriers and lack of free trade laws.

Also it is not laziness which limits people from using these resouces that may or may not exisit in a 'poor' persons backyard, but more likely it is the market forces at play on such resources. Lets take Zarf's example of food in an Urban setting. Food is a scarce resource because it is only produced on limited land. Now the lawyer in Zarf's example could increase the production of a food type, but would it be in his best interests? Thus it is not laziness that stops him producing food. Now he was earning a resonable wage in Zarf's example, but even if we reduce his wage it will still not be laziness that determines if he decides to produce food instead of be a lawyer.

The rest of your post does not even begin to respond to my postion and in fact is more of an example of your blind moronic adherance to a theoritical position that is incorrect. In any case, i am not avocating that everyone produce everything, nor that this is even remotely advantagous. What I am saying is that the prime reason for poverty is not laziness but greed coupled with scaricty of all resources (even O2.) The simple fact that everyone tries to get as much as they can of any one thing, and there is not infinite amount of any one resource, let alone the vast amounts of resources we consume daily, is the reason there is poverty. Laziness is but a secondary factor which is minor in a majority of cases and it is just the blind rhetoric of a moronic right that like to use laziness as justification for the selfish and greed driven idealogy they promote.

"Sticks and stones may break my bones, but i am Jesus"
"Nothing is worse than a fully prepared fool"

Re: Why are poor people poor?

Ignorwd for life unless your next post apologizes for direct attack and it is edited out.

Everything bad in the economy is now Obama's fault. Every job lost, all the debt, all the lost retirement funds. All Obama. Are you happy now? We all get to blame Obama!
Kemp currently not being responded to until he makes CONCISE posts.
Avogardo and Noir ignored by me for life so people know why I do not respond to them. (Informational)

68 (edited by You_Fool 06-Apr-2010 22:20:11)

Re: Why are poor people poor?

[appologies to flint and Zarf]

"Sticks and stones may break my bones, but i am Jesus"
"Nothing is worse than a fully prepared fool"

69 (edited by Zarf BeebleBrix 08-Apr-2010 01:43:20)

Re: Why are poor people poor?

[apology accepted]

Make Eyes Great Again!

The Great Eye is watching you... when there's nothing good on TV...

Re: Why are poor people poor?

oh shh Zarf...

"Sticks and stones may break my bones, but i am Jesus"
"Nothing is worse than a fully prepared fool"

Re: Why are poor people poor?

Does this mean i am being ignored? I deleted the offending comment...

"Sticks and stones may break my bones, but i am Jesus"
"Nothing is worse than a fully prepared fool"

Re: Why are poor people poor?

Maybe he's just offline.  tongue

Make Eyes Great Again!

The Great Eye is watching you... when there's nothing good on TV...

Re: Why are poor people poor?

Is possible..... who knows?

"Sticks and stones may break my bones, but i am Jesus"
"Nothing is worse than a fully prepared fool"

Re: Why are poor people poor?

No sincere apology, edit still allows insight and reference to attack.

This ignoring will not have my soul balanced against it, but without seeing a redemptive action of highest standards and eggshell walking til I am gone it will be followed in full strength.

Everything bad in the economy is now Obama's fault. Every job lost, all the debt, all the lost retirement funds. All Obama. Are you happy now? We all get to blame Obama!
Kemp currently not being responded to until he makes CONCISE posts.
Avogardo and Noir ignored by me for life so people know why I do not respond to them. (Informational)

75 (edited by You_Fool 06-Apr-2010 22:20:38)

Re: Why are poor people poor?

[Appologies to Zarf]

"Sticks and stones may break my bones, but i am Jesus"
"Nothing is worse than a fully prepared fool"