151

Re: Tell us why we don't believe in God

I'm sorry but before today i never heard of the intelligent design theorie. after googling it, it seems that it has been proven wrong, or to be some sort of form of creationisme(like releigion)??

science= explains things based on facts and their functionality  <-> creationisme's explanation= because the creator wanted it to be like that(or it says everything is created in function of the designers will/need)

So his point was that we shouldn't try to (dis)prove (or understand) theological stuff with( or through) facts ?



---------------------
"Its meant to demonstrate that just because something can't be disproven, doesn't mean it should be accepted, and hiding behind the "You can't prove its not ..." statement is paper thin at best. "

I fully agree with this, but that doesn't necesarely mean/prove something is wrong either(very very unlikely yes, but not enough to rule something out for 100%).

I think your example to clarify what he was trying to say actually confused me more ... lol. Maybe we should drop this example because it seems to be confusing instead of clarifying ?

Anyways,
The reason why his sentece doesn't make sense to me is that it looks like a false mathematical equation.
not knowing (or being able to)something = enough to disprove something. (how do know someone is wrong if you are not able to know? if you don't know, you can't exclude things for 100%)

Only the dead have seen the end of war. - Plato

Re: Tell us why we don't believe in God

> Levitas wrote:

> > SOL wrote:

> Yeah that's a very reliable source levitas. The guy who wrote that text is clearly not an idiot and knows perfectly how science works, he really did his homework before constructing his theory. (=sarcasm all the way)
That isn't even considered to be scientific at all.


It isn't meant to be serious, let alone scientific (They guy who wrote it actually holds a degree in physics by the way).  Its meant to demonstrate that just because something can't be disproven, doesn't mean it should be accepted, and hiding behind the "You can't prove its not ..." statement is paper thin at best.  His main point was that Intelligent Design not be taught in a scientific classroom.  Science uses facts, Intelligent Design does not. 

As far as wondering if I exist or not, cogito ergo sum (I think, therefore I am - Descartes).  If I exist, its stands to reason that my surroundings exist.  That's a good enough standard for me.  If you are wondering yourself if you exist, then you exist.


evolution isnt based on facts, its based off of assumptions too...

153 (edited by avogadro 02-Jan-2010 00:38:29)

Re: Tell us why we don't believe in God

creationism i think is typically what the people believe that think that the world is like only 10k years old or something; intelligent design however doesnt contradict any mainstream theories of how the earth or the universe was created; the only difference is while science will say the earth was created after the big bang by chance, intelligent design will say that the earth was formed by the big bang because it was designed to be created by the big bang by intelligent design... the classic statement for intelligent design is you walk in the park and find a a perfectly working watch on a tree stump. you can think that of all the millions of gears throughout the world, chances are that a few of these gears would fall perfectly into place by themselves to form a watch... or you can think someone designed and made the watch and then left it on the stump in the park...

Re: Tell us why we don't believe in God

Yo, diz is tha shit yo.

God is like, you know, a father figure... and wimpy gay folks obviously lacked one. So they made one up..which is cool'n'all, but yo, diz just aint tha truth !

.:: The History of God part 1  ::.
by Damon

Lets go back in time shall we. Before christianiy, before jews and muslims and heathens and whatnots.

Back in these times, humans beat eachother with rocks and clubs. The human way. The general consensus was if you got drugged and went on bad/good trips, you were a shaman and talked to the spirit world. These were their divine beliefs.

So some lesser tribe dude from another part of the county sees one dude freakin out high on drugs, and he sneaks up during the shamans comedown sleepsession, and snatches a furry pouch of drugs and gets real high. Someone see's him and suddenly he is a shaman too.

Now talking to the spirit world of course would make lesser tribe members believe they got an advantage on other tribes. I mean the spirits would let em know when to hunt, where to hunt, where to club a nice woman and important shit like that. So.. Tribes without spirit guidance would feel envy and thus the need to get a shaman for themselves. So they did and it spread out all through the woman-clubbin world.

People are human tho..thus territorial as whoever, whats mine is of course mine, and I dont necessarily wanna share... so people might have several shamans, but they wouldnt connect to the same spirits, individuality, power of drugs and all...

And seeing as people would compete over anything just to pass time, who has the bigger dad is not so much an important issue as who has biggest penis, spirit and club...

You get the idea here... easily comparable to the spaceprogramme in the 60ies...someone gets something, someone else gets something similar but NOT the same, and then starts competition.

The evolution (of course) would have to affect spirits too...

- Spirits

Served their purpose, defined specific areas of needed help and guidance.

- Lesser gods (multiple representatives of what was important in that culture ; the mythologies are in general a good example of this..its the spirits, just more powerful, more specified tasks, and more definable)

Would have more developed personalities, reflecting the mankind in evolution, more specific tasks and rivalries.

- Single god (The allmighty)

When someone has something better than you though..whats better than to just nuke em. This is the allmighty one god. He is the ace in the deck, the trumf of all trumfs. Mr Badass. They got 50 gods ? So what ? We got one, but he can do everything at the same time and is much stronger than your 50 combined ! This is the result of total lack of imagination and creativity in general. Basicly a get-out-of-jail-free-forever card. Practical though..saves time in prayers,  amount of offerings and needed diversity in the manner of faith.

And as all practical, cheap solutions, this was easily sold to humans. And with this god, like all other gods in history... he appear several places, in several branches of human faith, yet with slightly different ideas, appearances, names etc... But what you can wager all your money on, is that YOUR god is more important, stronger and more powerful than all the other gods..combined. Cause thats just what people thought 10.000 years ago.. while being REAL high on drugs, and if evolution ever told us something, its that some things never change.

So while some people might claim your god is :

- A life-boat for weakminded
- A figment of your imagination
- All powerful
- A rat bastard with inbred kids
- Whatever

I simply say your god is what your forefathers gave you after a bad night out, and you just cant get rid of it... kinda like an STD you got born with.

Enjoy !

.::: ______This is my world now_____ :::.
.:::_____D____A____M____O____N_____:::.
~Fight for your freedom or die enslaved~
~Lemming, Fft, Blue Wing, Viking, Nomad~

Re: Tell us why we don't believe in God

ha! its so funny because its plausable lol!

I dont smoke cigarettes because i like them.  I smoke because it hides the smell of marijuana thats seeping into the hallway atm.

Re: Tell us why we don't believe in God

Damon has many valid points as always. He's a genious simply by relation to me.

(ps. If you're a hot female and want to believe in God, call me, I'll show you the kingdom of Heaven)

You create your universe every step of the way.

Re: Tell us why we don't believe in God

> Calus wrote:

> Damon has many valid points as always.

really? name one

Re: Tell us why we don't believe in God

did you read damons post? i dont think calus needs to restate things that are only a few posts' up tongue

I dont smoke cigarettes because i like them.  I smoke because it hides the smell of marijuana thats seeping into the hallway atm.

159 (edited by avogadro 03-Jan-2010 03:50:59)

Re: Tell us why we don't believe in God

> Ehawk wrote:

> did you read damons post? i dont think calus needs to restate things that are only a few posts' up tongue


i read damon's post. i didnt see any valid points in it; but if you think there was a valid one, please post it separate so that i can judge its merit...

160 (edited by Skyroshroud 11-Jan-2010 14:34:27)

Re: Tell us why we don't believe in God

I'm confused as to what you don't consider a plausible theory Avogadro. It certainly makes more sense from a logical point of view than "God came down and showed himself to the world", since we've seen no sign of this for the last 2000 years. Other than 1 "shaman"(read: drugged up old guy) who came down from a mountain with some tablets he'd carved out, and a "virgin"(read: not virgin) giving birth to another.

Believing in your God just makes no [moo'ing] sense. Be it the muslim or christian God, their followers spew out all sorts of crazy shit in their name and die like the rest. Their followers get raped, murdered, abused, tortured, dismembered, the loss of family to bad people with bad intentions, all the while crying out for their Gods help. I think any person who chooses to love a God will find the love one-sided.

So if you still feel kinda spiritual but you've realised there is no holy father up in the clouds shagging angels and drinking wine, well, as I usually say, you create your own universe every step of the way. The spirituality you need you can find inside you, everything boils down to energy, everything is energy. Your God won't save your mother from being kidnapped and raped by ninjas. But you can.

Hence, Damon made valid points and expressed them in an amusing way:
+1 Damon
and
-1 avogadro
for not laughing.

You create your universe every step of the way.

Re: Tell us why we don't believe in God

Fine Avogrado, since you lack the will to understand history, I will give you something more...commentable ?
 
..:: Why I dont believe in god ::..
(PART 1 : Does god make mistakes ? by Damon)

~~~ First assumption : If there was a god he would be good at his job ~~~

Mankind have alot of bugs

- Moveable ears...but to no useful extent..they can be wiggled..its cool to look at..not useful in any way. Kinda like the VL tag in IC

- Goosebumps ...due to lack of hair this is another useless skill..BUT...if we were abit hairier it would raise our hair to protect from cold or fear...but yeah...no..malfunction, error, miscalculation.

- Recreational-system ...millions of sperm is required to make only a handful of babies over a lifetime. This seems vastly ineffective.

- Human jaw - Its too small...which is why the wisdom-teeth suck so much to get...

- Kidney's - In the womb we start with 6, or 3 sets... first set resembles that of a fish...second set that of an greater fish or amphibian...only the final set is what we keep... One could guess they act as levels of progress in development..but then again...couldnt we just start with one ?

- Limb-regeneration - Amphibians get it...humans...his most beloved creation...we didnt get it. Thanks alot God.

- Male nipples - They are useless. That said..with hormone treatment they aint..

- Human spine - Were not made for on two feet walking...its kinda stupid really..and in the middle of this is the spinal cord..I dont know how many off-days from work people get from backpain..but surely God would be able to foresee this in creation ?


DOES GOD MAKE MISTAKES ?

http://www.gotquestions.org/does-God-make-mistakes.html

.::: ______This is my world now_____ :::.
.:::_____D____A____M____O____N_____:::.
~Fight for your freedom or die enslaved~
~Lemming, Fft, Blue Wing, Viking, Nomad~

162

Re: Tell us why we don't believe in God

Damn you're an idiot.


How do you know it is a mistake? It might be just some sort of error margain that allows evolution to take place. Let's say if it was made 100% perfect, there would be no need to allow evolution/change. Allowing it not to be perfect, (might) requires room for error aswell. I know everything i said in my second point is purely hypothetical, and i find pointeless to debate wether that theory might be correct or not. The point i want to make is that you don't know it was a mistake. The room for error might aswell have been intended/necessary.  Perhaps the most perfect thing is allowing something not to be 100% perfect? My point is you(we) have no valid idea and you shouldn't assume you do.

You assume God exists, and if he does you assume he would make everything perfect. This proves my first point(see first sentence).

Only the dead have seen the end of war. - Plato

163 (edited by avogadro 03-Jan-2010 13:38:05)

Re: Tell us why we don't believe in God

"I'm confused as to what you don't consider a plausible theory Avogadro."

i didnt say it wasnt a plausible theory... i didnt see a valid point in it. Everyone knows theres a possibility that religion is wrong. his post simply restated that. no valid point to address.

164 (edited by avogadro 03-Jan-2010 13:46:52)

Re: Tell us why we don't believe in God

"~~~ First assumption : If there was a god he would be good at his job ~~~"

first what is God's "job" doesnt him having a "job" imply he is working for someone else? who is he working for?


as for all these flaws you list,  why would God want humans to be any different then they are?

Re: Tell us why we don't believe in God

SOL - Awesome, personal attacks in first line... <3 You rock, Mr.

The bible clearly states GOD IS FLAWLESS...perfect...best god in the world...etc tongue tongue tongue
Yet, his most beloved creation..oh and why is that anyways ? Only cause we can write and then read bibles ? We couldnt always...were we still most beloved ?
Anyways...yet still our body, which is molded in gods image is literally full of flaws. And these are flaws we all live with..there are several flaws less of us share.. like 11 fingers, 3 eyes, 2 heads, 2 bodies, no hair, no skin-color... Oh btw..you do know all these people were regarded as abominations to the lord, and evil only a couple hundred years back ?

As human evolves, so does the religion...in such a way I can claim christianity is only a reflection of mankind at in its current era, and what they believe to be decent guidelines on behaviour. Screw that..if your mother didnt teach you how to behave how is an inperfect god going to ? You could at least SEE your mother shaking the saucepan tongue

What is christianity going to be a hundred years from now ? Will it be in sync with your current beliefs ? If your only belief is in the one true god yoy might aswell be muslim you know wink

.::: ______This is my world now_____ :::.
.:::_____D____A____M____O____N_____:::.
~Fight for your freedom or die enslaved~
~Lemming, Fft, Blue Wing, Viking, Nomad~

166

Re: Tell us why we don't believe in God

I was kinda hoping you were a big idiot and would make a big scene by calling you an idiot, in wich case you would have proven my point tongue.

Only the dead have seen the end of war. - Plato

Re: Tell us why we don't believe in God

If that was a big scene where you are from, I'd say you are proving my view on christians not experiencing life smile

.::: ______This is my world now_____ :::.
.:::_____D____A____M____O____N_____:::.
~Fight for your freedom or die enslaved~
~Lemming, Fft, Blue Wing, Viking, Nomad~

168

Re: Tell us why we don't believe in God

i said i was hoping you would, i didn't say i saw the scene i was hoping for.

"I'd say you are proving my view on christians not experiencing life"

So you're assuming i'm christian just because i was disagreeing with your criticism on christianity? Now you are proving my point tongue

Only the dead have seen the end of war. - Plato

Re: Tell us why we don't believe in God

lol this is getting retarded and off-topic. I'm ahead of myself assuming a defender of christianity is a christian ? Who cares ?

Lets get back on topic shall we ,)

.::: ______This is my world now_____ :::.
.:::_____D____A____M____O____N_____:::.
~Fight for your freedom or die enslaved~
~Lemming, Fft, Blue Wing, Viking, Nomad~

Re: Tell us why we don't believe in God

someone calls you an idiot and all of a sudden he's a defender of christianity and a christian?

Re: Tell us why we don't believe in God

You obviously have a problem reading the entire posts Avogadro..get back to me when you've taken the time.

.::: ______This is my world now_____ :::.
.:::_____D____A____M____O____N_____:::.
~Fight for your freedom or die enslaved~
~Lemming, Fft, Blue Wing, Viking, Nomad~

172 (edited by SOL 03-Jan-2010 18:55:42)

Re: Tell us why we don't believe in God

I'll let you in on a little secret: i'm not christian. I even agree that the bible is pretty damn flawed, and that the relegion based on flawed book is very likely to be crap aswell. I was criticizing your arguement. your agruement was that the human species aren't perfect, as the bible states. My question to you was : How do you know things aren't perfect the way they are right now?(or as perfect as it can get). See the post where i first stated my point that you were an idiot.

You actually suprised(dissapointed me and my theory) in your reply to that post by not acting like a wild redneck. Your posts that followed on the otherhand....

"lol this is getting retarded and off-topic. I'm ahead of myself assuming a defender of christianity is a christian ? Who cares ?"
--> you ask who cares? well you obviously do.

You thought i was a christain, and therefore failed/refused to take me posts serious. The result is that you couldn't(or refused to try to) getmy point. YOu let your emotions cloud your thinking, wich makes you an idiot.

Even if that wasn't through, and you didn't care whether i was christian or not, that would mean you have some sort or reading dissability(irony-->read his previous post) or something that made you fail to get my point while other do get it. This also fals under the definition of "idiot".

http://dictionary.reference.com/browse/idiot --> 1.     an utterly foolish or senseless person

Only the dead have seen the end of war. - Plato

Re: Tell us why we don't believe in God

"lol this is getting retarded and off-topic. I'm ahead of myself assuming a defender of christianity is a christian ? Who cares ?"
--> you ask who cares? well you obviously do.

-> Obviously the both of you do too...and again..my premature assumptions may be wrong, but its still completely off-topic..and then what is the point in keeping this on ?

I was wrong in assuming you were christian, and I admit it freely to anyone who is willing to listen, can we get on to the topic at hand and do something more interesting than assuming things about eachother ?

.::: ______This is my world now_____ :::.
.:::_____D____A____M____O____N_____:::.
~Fight for your freedom or die enslaved~
~Lemming, Fft, Blue Wing, Viking, Nomad~

174

Re: Tell us why we don't believe in God

Sure, and don't worry ... it takes one to know one smile

Only the dead have seen the end of war. - Plato

Re: Tell us why we don't believe in God

calus wrote:
"I think any person who chooses to love a God will find the love one-sided."

haha! thats freakin awesome! big_smile

damon wrote:
"What is christianity going to be a hundred years from now ?"

i dont think christianity will exist, if it does, it will be taboo, islam is going to probably take over.  that brings me to my next theory: no matter what religions have the earth, atheism will always be with us just as it always was with us! smile
____________________
back to my ranting,

the orional topic was about why we dont believe:  i think we can break this down in to categories.

type 1: intellegent person - someone who chooses not to believe because their intelligence allows them to see flaws in the religious institutions and ultimately resist God.  this does not mean that god doesn't exist, it just a simple human rejection of god with logic as the conduit.

type 2: inferiority complex: a person that denies or rejects God due to the psychological response to an unwilling destiny.  simply a person that doen't like the idea of a deity in control of thier destiny.

type 3: Carnage Recipient - a person whom seen carnage and/or war and reject belief because experiences make the person feel that God isn't real.

NOTE- these categories are meant for only atheist, agnostics are not part of these types. ALSO! atheism is NOT a religion.  we atheist are all different, it is merely imposable to assertain any specific reason why atheists reject god.  but with surveys and research, you can pick up signs of why particular individuals choose to reject God. 

i will allow this to sinc in and marinate in your brains for a moment, as i will be posting a reply to damons' theory. big_smile

I dont smoke cigarettes because i like them.  I smoke because it hides the smell of marijuana thats seeping into the hallway atm.