Re: Tell us why we don't believe in God

every christian is different. every muslim is different...

the individual doesnt define language, the culture does, and the culture says atheists beleive there is no God and Agnostics dont have a beleif in whether or not there is a God...

Re: Tell us why we don't believe in God

since thats cleared up...

now we have a standard definition of atheism. moving on, fokker asked "why"

i think there may be a human instinct to question and find truth.  Perhaps Atheism as a whole, may be the result of humans rejecting belief in which there is no answers. i'm not saying that theists' aren't using a natural human insticts.  after all, finding faith may also be a human instinct aswell.  So, "why we dont believe?" is simple...
We are the human animal, we are strong, proud and creative. Artistic and intelectual, we have needs.  These needs include a deep inner impulse to find meanings(in everything!) in life. A result of this was Religion, a organized beliefs system to answer most life questions and guide people away from their destructive super-ego. there were many stories, mostly based on astronimical observations. As cultures clashed, so did their belief systems. just like evolution, the strogest survived and the weakest died off, our species then experienced, over a few thousand year, a series of "rise and fall" of cultures. ultamately bringing us to the current cultural systems we have today.  Religions are the humanistic coping mechanism our brains require for proliferation and order. an Atheist simiply rejects God because the idea of his existence is believed to be the result of human disire for happy endings.

this is why.

I dont smoke cigarettes because i like them.  I smoke because it hides the smell of marijuana thats seeping into the hallway atm.

Re: Tell us why we don't believe in God

Marx once said "Religion is the opium of the masses"


I'm too lazy to read all the 5 pages now, I have exams, once they're done today I may have more to say or something more intellectual to point out, but for now, I'lll simply agree with Ehawk's last post above mine

Insane Lemming of Drama Queens and Other Hyperbolical People

1431 ftw

Re: Tell us why we don't believe in God

hey death, i thought you were gonna pay me a visit, due to my death post... tongue lmao

I dont smoke cigarettes because i like them.  I smoke because it hides the smell of marijuana thats seeping into the hallway atm.

Re: Tell us why we don't believe in God

So you think Atheism is gaining popularity because humans have finally matured enough to be able to handle the knowlege that we just die* and the imaginary power that comes from knowing that we are ultimately only accountable to ourselves?


*unlike my dog Deifer, who ran away to the farm big_smile

"So, it's defeat for you, is it? Someday I must meet a similar fate..."

Re: Tell us why we don't believe in God

"humans have finally matured enough to be able to handle the knowlege that we just die"

a species maturity is related to average IQ and intelligence.  so now, we are back where we started! IN YO FACE AVO!!!

GO FOKKER! lol big_smile

I dont smoke cigarettes because i like them.  I smoke because it hides the smell of marijuana thats seeping into the hallway atm.

Re: Tell us why we don't believe in God

> Ehawk wrote:

> "humans have finally matured enough to be able to handle the knowlege that we just die"

a species maturity is related to average IQ and intelligence.  so now, we are back where we started! IN YO FACE AVO!!!

GO FOKKER! lol big_smile


and who is the one thats doing it? Fokker, the person accusing me of arguing in circles...

Re: Tell us why we don't believe in God

thats the fun part! because everyone is doing it! lol

I dont smoke cigarettes because i like them.  I smoke because it hides the smell of marijuana thats seeping into the hallway atm.

Re: Tell us why we don't believe in God

The purpose of this thread was for one person to answer the question in the original post, and that person has repeatedly avoided answering this simple question by:

1> Pretending the original question (which is also the thread title) was too difficult to understand.

2> Pretending that the quote was a misquote.

3> Searching for tiny points of contention.

4> Starting multiple, apparently random, arguments by picking on small grammatical errors, then pretending the small errors have changed the meaning of the entire question.

5> Starting multiple, apparently random, arguments by picking on small differences in definition, then pretending the small differences in definition have changed the meaning of the entire question.

6> Answering questions, challenges and posts using strategies and tactics, rather than truth, facts and personal opinion, in a manner that is designed to keep the discussion going rather than to resolve anything.

  And now that person is accusing me of such things, such circular arguing, seemingly because I won't forget that the only purpose of this thread is for him to finish his statement, for him to tell us why we don't believe in God:


Avogadro wrote:

> while you may not beleive in a god, dont delude yourself into believing that the reason you dont beleive in a god is a result of your intelligence, IQ, education, or ability to think for yourself... <

  Pray-tell, what is the reason?

"So, it's defeat for you, is it? Someday I must meet a similar fate..."

Re: Tell us why we don't believe in God

So you think Atheism is gaining popularity because humans have finally matured enough to be able to handle the knowlege that we just die* and the imaginary power that comes from knowing that we are ultimately only accountable to ourselves?

Oh? So what was wrong with the Third Reich? It was too hard to get membership?

The core joke of Hitchhiker's Guide to the Galaxy is that of course no civilization would develop personal computers with instant remote database recovery, and then waste this technology to find good drinks.
Steve Jobs has ruined this joke.

Re: Tell us why we don't believe in God

lol

"So, it's defeat for you, is it? Someday I must meet a similar fate..."

Re: Tell us why we don't believe in God

Before I get started, I just want to outline my belief structure a little bit.  I'm an agnostic, but I find religions and beliefs to be very good conversation, so long as both parties keep it mature.  I have several friends that have strong religious beliefs and I love widdleing away the hours talking to them about such things.  The LAST thing I ever want to do is convince someone that their faith is misplaced.  I don't want someone that will cave and say "You're right, I've wasted my life" ... I don't want you to convince me that your religion is right for me, I've made my choice, I want you to convince yourself that its right for you.

I think the question that Ehawk raised about why people believe is far more fascinating than why people don't believe.  If I can for just one moment step into the shoes of one of those pompous douche bags that ask and then answer their own questions, I have a question that I will ask and then answer ...

For those Catholics out there, as this thread seems to be dealing with them more than other religions, Why Catholicism?  Why not Judaism?  Or Buddhism, or Muslim, or any of the other religions on this planet?  Do not the other religions offer the same eternal bliss?  Do not the other religions have similar rules and restrictions on how that eternal bliss is achieved? 

Some people come to God on their own terms, their own tragedies and failures looking for guidence, those are not the people I will be addressing. 

The answer that is most commonly given to this question is "My parents raised me to be a Catholic, so I'm a Catholic".  Ok, so that means these people are Catholics because of the social implications involved.  If they don't believe this, then they may be disowned, ridiculed, and so on ...  This then begs the question, Why did your parents choose Catholicism?  Then again with the answer of that's how they were raised and this cycle repeats until we down to the real answer.  The reason that people who were raised as Catholics are Catholics is because of where their ancestors were born.  They are letting something as arbitrary as the birthplace of someone hundreds, if not thousand of years dead decide the final resting place of their soul.  Some people will take this as "I'm trying to remain close to my ancestors with strong family traditions".  Well, some of those ansestors were forced to religion as the social implications then were far more dangerous then the ones we face now.  And there is lies the question; Why do you Believe?  What makes your religion work for you? 

I don't want an answer to this question for my own sake, I just want people to look at the decisions they've made and be happy with them, they are in fact your decisions.  If there is a God, he gave us free will for a reason.  The free will to choose to love God.  When you die and you go to that eternal bliss that I hope you achieve and you are before whatever God you believe in, if he asks you "Why do YOU love me?", "Because my Mom told me too" seems like a pretty incomplete answer.

Current Status: Done with Imperial Conflict

113 (edited by avogadro 30-Dec-2009 20:56:10)

Re: Tell us why we don't believe in God

"  Pray-tell, what is the reason?"

there isnt a single reason...  the quote you gave was simply pointing out that the difference between an atheists and  christians is not "intelligence, IQ, education, or ability to think for yourself"

"The purpose of this thread was for one person to answer the question in the original post, and that person has repeatedly avoided answering this simple question by:"

why was a new thread required for that? if that is the sole purpose of this thread, to take a fraction of one of my sentences out of context, quote it, and ask me some bs question, then you could/should of done it in the same thread... but no, you were decided cryptic, it took you nearly a month after the OP to say what you wanted me to do... i had a valid question, you took a quote from me and asked the question, you did not clearly address the question clearly towards me so i asked if it was directed at me and you didnt answer and its taking you this long to finally answer it because you were caught arguing in circles and want to change focus of the thread...

114 (edited by avogadro 30-Dec-2009 23:29:24)

Re: Tell us why we don't believe in God

> Levitas wrote:

>
The answer that is most commonly given to this question is "My parents raised me to be a Catholic, so I'm a Catholic".  Ok, so that means these people are Catholics because of the social implications involved.  If they don't believe this, then they may be disowned, ridiculed, and so on ...  This then begs the question, Why did your parents choose Catholicism?  Then again with the answer of that's how they were raised and this cycle repeats until we down to the real answer.  The reason that people who were raised as Catholics are Catholics is because of where their ancestors were born.  They are letting something as arbitrary as the birthplace of someone hundreds, if not thousand of years dead decide the final resting place of their soul.  Some people will take this as "I'm trying to remain close to my ancestors with strong family traditions".  Well, some of those ansestors were forced to religion as the social implications then were far more dangerous then the ones we face now.  And there is lies the question; Why do you Believe?  What makes your religion work for you? 

I don't want an answer to this question for my own sake, I just want people to look at the decisions they've made and be happy with them, they are in fact your decisions.  If there is a God, he gave us free will for a reason.  The free will to choose to love God.  When you die and you go to that eternal bliss that I hope you achieve and you are before whatever God you believe in, if he asks you "Why do YOU love me?", "Because my Mom told me too" seems like a pretty incomplete answer.


you said yourself, there isnt much difference between most of the modern religions, why does it matter why they chose that particular religion. you could take that same line of reasoning for science. everything you or i believe is because of society. the difference between us and cavemen is whats been passed down from our ancestors..

Re: Tell us why we don't believe in God

avo, sorry, you cannot relate that reasoning with science, but nice try.  Science must go through immense scrutany and debate to proove without a doubt, the theory and/or scientific ideas are in fact true and correct, and in any case there is any incorrect material, the international community will publically make the adjustments to correct the errors.  I have yet to see ANY religious belief system go through the checks and procedures like science has!  when have you EVER seen any international scrutany to check the truth and correctness of the bible? You see, religious belief are trusted and accepted on faith. For hundreds even thousands of years, questioning the socially accepted religions were to be considered "taboo". 

@levi, great job, that was a well explained, non-bias explaination of the process in which religions indoctrine its followers and stand the test of time.  the "evolution" of human beliefs! well done! big_smile

I dont smoke cigarettes because i like them.  I smoke because it hides the smell of marijuana thats seeping into the hallway atm.

Re: Tell us why we don't believe in God

Science

1. Bases its theories on empirical evidence
2. Assumes that evidence correlates with reality or what is true

#2 can not be justified. We have no independent access to reality to observe that it does.

Re: Tell us why we don't believe in God

do you think that the combine point of view from many people coordinating and confirmations is good enough to justify partial access to reality observations? just wondering...

I dont smoke cigarettes because i like them.  I smoke because it hides the smell of marijuana thats seeping into the hallway atm.

Re: Tell us why we don't believe in God

i didnt claim that science and religion are the same thing ehawk... science is a product of information being passed down from our ancestor's just like religion though..

Re: Tell us why we don't believe in God

> Ehawk wrote:

> do you think that the combine point of view from many people coordinating and confirmations is good enough to justify partial access to reality observations? just wondering...


it cannot be for the simple reason that you think you know of multiple people confirming something by your single point of view...

120 (edited by Ehawk 31-Dec-2009 02:17:51)

Re: Tell us why we don't believe in God

avo wrote:
"science is a product of information being passed down from our ancestor's just like religion though.."

true, but science is allowed to change, religion has traditions that would jeopardise the its religion if changed...

avo wrote:
"it cannot be for the simple reason that you think you know of multiple people confirming something by your single point of view..."

no, i didn't mean it like that.  i asked justinian because what he meant was that the concept of reality is not certain because human sense are not valid instruments for truth... we recieve messages from our senses and then our brain interprets the messages, this can be considered not a viable source of reality.

i was wondering in the multiple peoples' perspective can be considered enough to be reality...

I dont smoke cigarettes because i like them.  I smoke because it hides the smell of marijuana thats seeping into the hallway atm.

121 (edited by avogadro 31-Dec-2009 02:33:19)

Re: Tell us why we don't believe in God

"
true, but science is allowed to change, religion has traditions that would jeopardise the its religion if changed..."

religions change fairly dramatically too... religions are formed by men and most recognize this and acknowledge that men make mistakes and that their institution isnt perfect...

"
no, i didn't mean it like that.  i asked justinian because what he meant was that the concept of reality is not certain because human sense are not valid instruments for truth... we recieve messages from our senses and then our brain interprets the messages, this can be considered not a viable source of reality.

i was wondering in the multiple peoples' perspective can be considered enough to be reality..."

yeah, and when someone confirms your concept of reality,  do you not receive this confirmation through the same human senses that are not valid instruments for truth?

Re: Tell us why we don't believe in God

if one person has a piont of view, this is their belief based on their interpretation of reality.  My question is: When millions of people generally accept a specific point of view, does this constitute as a valueable perspective on reality?

note: yes, i should have mentioned this question was based on "millions" of people, not just one other person agreeing with another...

I dont smoke cigarettes because i like them.  I smoke because it hides the smell of marijuana thats seeping into the hallway atm.

123 (edited by avogadro 31-Dec-2009 03:08:17)

Re: Tell us why we don't believe in God

"millions" is measured by the human senses, the invalid instruments... you can ask 1 million people what they see and they might all agree with you, but they might all not exist anywhere other then your mind, they might be your mind misinterpreting signals sent to it by the senses...  millions of people are simply a construct of your senses and mind... if millions of people's view counts as reality, then a single person's view must count as reality...

Re: Tell us why we don't believe in God

> Ehawk wrote:

> do you think that the combine point of view from many people coordinating and confirmations is good enough to justify partial access to reality observations? just wondering...>

Nope. Actually, I give up on truth all together. But I think human reason has some ability to theorize and predict outcomes in what is phenomenal, but whether what is phenomenon is an illusion or has some partial correlation to reality is presently impossible to know.

Re: Tell us why we don't believe in God

A dutch comedian once said 'Beethoven's fifth symphony was made up, but that does not mean it is not there.'

I think there is truth in that.

If you ask me, god has been created by humans rather than the other way around, but that does not mean he's not there, because the fact people change their behaviour for him kinda of means he is.

NEE NAW NEE NAW

Primo