Re: USA Doomed?
> Ehawk wrote:
> i have no arguement with that, justinian hit the nail on the head. our elites are absolutely driven by short term gain.
@justinian, how do you think a dictatorship would actually start? military coup d'etat? or simply a fall of economics that result in localized governments?>
The historical record suggests when the elites fail to supply the goods and services expected of them (whether it's economic, administrative or even security), new suppliers emerge on to the scene. For example, toward the end of the Roman Republic, the nobility caused the number of urban poor to explode. All Marius or Caesar needed to do to gain popular support was to institute themselves as the people's champion. In the case of the French Revolution, the ancient regime neglected and exploited the people to the point that they caused the circumstances that lead to their own demise. The subsequent regimes also failed until Napoleon was able to deliver long lasting security and effective government. In modern times, communities where the government has little presence have also gone to alternative suppliers, like mercenaries for security.
What I see today is that the American elite are neglecting the welfare of the American people for their own short-term gain, and if history serves as a reliable reference the people will eventually go to an alternative supplier. I do not know who, what or how, but I have my doubts that it will be done democratically or that there will be no supplier with the presence over a large land mass. For the former, the elite have a firm grip on the democratic process and can legally ruin any one who opposes their interests. However, my estimation is that there will be some sort of armed overthrow. Second, no office has sufficient power to make the necessary reforms. Third, even if a populist gained a high office, it is doubtful that the elite would be unable to stop an effective populist coalition in either legislative house. For the latter, it is very possible that America could be split between two or more countries with a powerful government presence, but technology and infrastructure makes it impossible to have several small autonomous communities like the Greek polis.