1 (edited by Justinian I 17-Jul-2008 08:36:01)

Topic: Are black peope discriminated against?

I am actually ignorant of this question. That's why I'm asking. Are black people discriminated against by law enforcement and citizens in the US for the only reason of being black?

Thoughts?

My immediate thought is no. This talk about discrimination is not due to race, but appearance. You dress like you're from the hood, you get treated like you're from the hood. I think this because I have a friend who, though white, was discriminated against by police for dressing like a "punk." I have also heard of teenage discrimination, but I never was discriminated by police, probably because I act civilized, dress appropriately, and don't drive like an idiot.

Secondly, I have an Indian friend who could never get hired because he dressed inappropriately. He blamed it on racism. I told him to stop applying for Target in a suit, and dress a little more casually. He was finally hired at the next place he applied to.

My best friend is also black. Though he has been a target of racial slurs, he has no problems getting hired, with the police, or with his all white neighbors. What separates him apart is that he is intelligent, articulate, and minds his appearance (doesn't dress like some person in "da hood").

Re: Are black peope discriminated against?

Agreed and agreed. Racism is only practiced by a miniscule white minority and by the majority of blacks and hispanics in this nation. Blacks only suffer racism in sufficient levels from Hispanics any more.

Everything bad in the economy is now Obama's fault. Every job lost, all the debt, all the lost retirement funds. All Obama. Are you happy now? We all get to blame Obama!
Kemp currently not being responded to until he makes CONCISE posts.
Avogardo and Noir ignored by me for life so people know why I do not respond to them. (Informational)

Re: Are black peope discriminated against?

If you haven't seen Harold and Kumar: Escape from Guantanamo Bay
you should see it because the whole plot is based on appearances and race.

"Whoever said the pen is mightier than the sword obviously never encountered
automatic weapons."-General Douglas MacArthur
"Cluster bombing from B-52s are very, very, accurate. The bombs are guaranteed
to always hit the ground."-USAF Ammo Troop

4 (edited by The Nolio Show 17-Jul-2008 10:55:48)

Re: Are black peope discriminated against?

lol I for one know that black people are indeed discriminated against being black myself. As far as the appearance thing....it doesn't really matter how you dress, a person who is racist is going to be racist no matter what.

I dress in suits or just a shirt and tie at work, polo T's and jeans when I'm out, slacks/jeans and a long button up the rest of the time. Every once in a while you'll see me in something that I suppose would associate me with "da hood" but regardless of how I dress, ever heard of the expression that "clothes don't make the man"?

The way that a person dictates themselves, speaks toward others and conducts their buisness should be the determining factor as to whether that person is acceptable to be in your personal company. The appearance situation is going to be a situation because it associates a person with a particular race. It's different if you're in a certain enviornment where there is a dress code, but otherwise, it's all racial.

I've had police pull me over simply because my car doesn't look like anything that they feel I could afford and give me tickets for something as miniscule as driving while on a cell phone. Despite the fact that I was calling to tell my job that I was running 10 minutes late. Cops have pulled me over simply because they were "Doing routine stops". I've had a policeman pull me over because I bought a new car and he wanted to verify that I was the owner. No matter how you see it, it's racial profiling. Something that you can't understand unless you're the target of it. I'm not saying 100% of all incidents where someone claims discrimination is true, but I seriously doubt you Flint or you Justin can comprehend the embarassment and sheer harassment that the law enforcement can give to a person.

The name that you hand in on your job application can get you turned away from employers because they feel that you don't fit the description of what they want without even reading your application. I've seen this first hand.

Anyhow, this is not an argument that a person who isn't a target of racism can really give accurate feedback to.

Sex without the e is still SX!

5 (edited by Justinian I 17-Jul-2008 11:42:34)

Re: Are black peope discriminated against?

Nolio,

Oh I disagree. It makes you more qualified than a victim of racial profiling. The reason is that your emotions color the topic much less, enabling you to have a fresher, more objective analysis. With a careful scientific investigation, the evidence will guarantee a conclusion. A wrong conclusion is due to either false reasoning or insufficient evidence. The former is a very real risk among an actual victim. As I mentioned my Indian friend, he blamed all his problems on racism. His emotions clouded his reasoning, but when I analyzed his problems further his problems were due to very different causes. I have also noticed that the racist attribution is very common among minority groups of lower classes.

Not that racism and racial profiling don't happen, but I think they are overblown. I think what we consider racial profiling is really class profiling. My middle class black friend has negligible problems with racial profiling and racism, and so does my Asian aunt. Yes my Asian aunt has been assumed to be a terrorist before, but in most cases she receives the treatment of her class, a woman of the upper middle class who earns a six figure income. The same is true of my black friend, who is very middle class. He is not treated like someone in the hood.

Second, white people who can be inferred as being in a lower class are perceived the same way. I also have a white acquaintance from the working class who has a nice sports car, he has a lease for it, and he is consistently pulled over by the police for asinine reasons like a warning that his tabs expire in a few weeks.

With the evidence available to me, it seems to me that racism and racial profiling is much rarer than its made out to be. Most of the cases are class profiling and classism. Now I agree that black people have a harder time persuading the police and citizenry that they are hard working, educated, and not from a lower class, but it can be pulled off and the harassment severely reduced to the point of being negligible.

Re: Are black peope discriminated against?

"as miniscule as driving while on a cell phone"

is talking on the phone while driving against the law in your state?

Brother Simon, Keeper of Ages, Defender of Faith.
~ ☭ Fokker

Re: Are black peope discriminated against?

i'm getting rather sick of the constant shouting of "racism".
it's starting to become a real fashion word

the other day there was an official complaint to the FIFA by a comittee against racism about dutch football supporters singing a song  in which someone was accused of being gay.
since when are homosexuals a race?
apperantly it's the best way to get attention.

NEE NAW NEE NAW

Primo

Re: Are black peope discriminated against?

lol no Simon, it surely isn't. And I got the ticket overturned in court.

Justin, I'm not letting my emotions cloud my reasoning or influence my judgement.

There are all kinds of things that go on here in the united states that are obviously racism.

For example, 3 young caucasian men in their 20's decided to one day beat up a black man who was 43 years old I believe. He was just getting off the bus on his way home from work when they jumped on him. He was sent to the hospital and is now permanently brain damaged with 3 children and a single father. The men who beat him up were released after 6 weeks in jail and given probation. The man can never work again due to his condition. He won a lawsuit that his relatives filed for him but the men pretty much got off scot free.


Ok not long after that, there was a case where a white guy in high school hung a noose on the cafeteria table where this group of black kids liked to sit outside. He mocked one of the boys who found it there and the two got into a shouting match. The black kid and 5 of his friends beat up the white kid ended up getting into a fight (both were 16 I think) and they both got sent home. Later on that night, there was a school dance and the kids who sat at the table and the white kid and some of his friends went to the dance.

More words were exchanged, initated by the white kid and one of the boys got into a fight with the white kid. The school then called the police and both parties were made to leave.


The white kid was suspended from school for 3 days, the 6 black kids were thrown in jail and charged with aggravated assault, attempted murder and some other charges. One was a 17 year old football player at the school and he was facing 20 years in prison with adult charges. Some of the others were facing similar charges with the minimum being 3 years in prison. All were facing expulsion.


I hear about crap like this all the time. So you'll have to excuse me if I deny your statement justin that racism are overblown. While I do believe that a lot of situations use the word racism loosely like Primo stated, the situation in America for minorities is extreme. Again, if you haven't experienced it then you can't understand it.

Sex without the e is still SX!

Re: Are black peope discriminated against?

But you do however mention the class situation. How do you think that these minorities are in these classes?

1. Little to no money goes to improving neighborhoods in which the majority of its residents are minorities.

2. Funding for public schools is greater in areas where minorities make up a smaller percentage as opposed to the schools where they are the greater. The only exception is in which the sports program is extremely high and that's only because it is likely to have a profitable outcome with ticket sales and such.

3. In my state, we have 3 schools which are consistently in the top 1-10 categories in the nation in various fields. One of which is the top medical research school in the nation. All of these schools had budget cuts and they all cut their african american studies departments. The University that I attend has fraternities and soroties but none of them have houses for the black fraternities and soroties. Only the white.

4. Recently a study was done and showed that Wal-Mart, one of America's top retailers, were not promoting black and hispanic managers in stores where buisness was good. These managers were instead moved to locations where buisness was poor.

I could go on and on but it really makes no difference. You have to walk in the shoes to understand what goes on. Very few ppl want to live in "the hood". There's no glory in not knowing where your next meal is going to come from, having the police who do come to the neighborhood do more damage than good, attending a school where the classes are overpopulated and the books are falling apart and the parks are not equipped with tools to keep the kids off the streets.

Sex without the e is still SX!

10 (edited by tavius 17-Jul-2008 13:33:20)

Re: Are black peope discriminated against?

Agreed. Racism still takes place, however the conditions have improved and people know to be more subtle or evasive about it now. Although nowadays it's becoming more acceptable for someone confronted about it to simply say everyone else is being too politically correct, or that they can't possibly be racist because they've got <insert race> friend/wife.

Re: Are black peope discriminated against?

Quit voting Democrat, vote Republican. If you do (as a segment of the population) then I guarantee complaints about profiling police wont get shit canned, I guarantee that courts will be told to sentence fairly, I guarantee instead of refurbishing white areas with 'urban renewal funds' you will see ghetto's getting fixed up. I guarantee vouchers will be on the agenda until it finally happens. Everything that holds you down is Democrat, let that thing go man!


And I have to ask on the frat house thing. Do you stand for most of other blacks and what they do? Or do you disagree with most of them? And I have been in enough area's to know what I am talking about here, and you know what I am talking about as well. The under 25 crowd.

Everything bad in the economy is now Obama's fault. Every job lost, all the debt, all the lost retirement funds. All Obama. Are you happy now? We all get to blame Obama!
Kemp currently not being responded to until he makes CONCISE posts.
Avogardo and Noir ignored by me for life so people know why I do not respond to them. (Informational)

Re: Are black peope discriminated against?

lol I like some of the Republican views but I have yet to see a republican candidate that I feel comfortable with. I personally am not into the frat thing myself. Never cared for them. Maybe I'm just not a group person =p

But anyhow the discrimination in America and the world for that matter goes so far beyond black and white. The reason why your argument cannot really hold much weight with me Justin is because there are all kinds of things going on that are overlooked/forgotten. Some people are not getting hired because they are overweight. A lot of stores in malls, particularly clothing stores won't hire you if you are overweight. They want to attract "pretty" people. I've read this in an article last year.

Jewish people are discriminated against as heavily as blacks are.

Homosexuals are probably the most discriminated against worldwide.

Women (as shown by the democratic election this year) still have a ton of bias towards them.

Muslims are catching incredible heat and have been since 9/11 occurred.

Military veterans, Pregnant women, Christians, Teenagers, Computer "Geeks".....

I don't really care for discrimination discussions too much because people seem to discuss black/white a lot but there are other discrimination targets who have it just as bad or even worse:p

Honestly I'd hate to be a gay muslim in America right now =o

Sex without the e is still SX!

Re: Are black peope discriminated against?

I would never vote for Hillary, I would vote for Osama Bin Ladin before I voted for her. But to say sexism? No, it's anti-Clintonism.

I would have voted for Rice in a heart beat. I would have voted Mrs Dole as well if she had made it. I would never vote basedupon sex, nor would most Republicans. If you want a female president then vote one in which is not a Hillary nor a Pelosi. Vote in a Dolly Madison and I will say heck yes! Vote a Margaret Chase Smith in and I will cheer. But the rest of your choices, they suck.

Everything bad in the economy is now Obama's fault. Every job lost, all the debt, all the lost retirement funds. All Obama. Are you happy now? We all get to blame Obama!
Kemp currently not being responded to until he makes CONCISE posts.
Avogardo and Noir ignored by me for life so people know why I do not respond to them. (Informational)

Re: Are black peope discriminated against?

http://z.about.com/d/politicalhumor/1/0/Z/c/dem_vs_republican_women.jpg


btw just showing the difference in appearance also tongue

Everything bad in the economy is now Obama's fault. Every job lost, all the debt, all the lost retirement funds. All Obama. Are you happy now? We all get to blame Obama!
Kemp currently not being responded to until he makes CONCISE posts.
Avogardo and Noir ignored by me for life so people know why I do not respond to them. (Informational)

15 (edited by Gwynedd 18-Jul-2008 23:13:04)

Re: Are black peope discriminated against?

obviously racism does exist, the question of how often someone is discriminated against because of race is alot less clear. about the 2 situations you gave with the assault. it could be as simple as the white men having better lawyers or the parents of the white kid could of pushed the police to press more charges.

and nolio, were there really separate fraternities for blacks and whites at your college? thats [shoe polish] up.

Re: Are black peope discriminated against?

the problem isn't racism. the problem is louisiana

Re: Are black peope discriminated against?

Oh he lives in Louisiana? Oh I am sorry, that State is never going to recover, never going to be free of Democrat control and of corruption until a pure Republican group is put in sometime in the year 2300.

Everything bad in the economy is now Obama's fault. Every job lost, all the debt, all the lost retirement funds. All Obama. Are you happy now? We all get to blame Obama!
Kemp currently not being responded to until he makes CONCISE posts.
Avogardo and Noir ignored by me for life so people know why I do not respond to them. (Informational)

18 (edited by avogadro 17-Jul-2008 19:42:34)

Re: Are black peope discriminated against?

another thing. police officers that patrol teh streets are working class, so the idea that police officers discriminate against the working class, is pretty far-fetched. if they discriminate against anyone its the upper class and upper middle class.  the times you were pulled over in a nice car was probably because they thought you were rich and were harassing you because you make more money then them and not because you're black.  when i was in nice clothes, driving a nice, practically new car, i got a ticket for going 3mph about the speed limit; when i was driving in dirty, beat-up clothes, in an old car and got pulled over going 30mph above the speed limit, and told the officer i was heading back from work at 7 am, i was given a warning.

"Jewish people are discriminated against as heavily as blacks are.

Homosexuals are probably the most discriminated against worldwide.

Women (as shown by the democratic election this year) still have a ton of bias towards them.

Muslims are catching incredible heat and have been since 9/11 occurred.

Military veterans, Pregnant women, Christians, Teenagers, Computer "Geeks".....

I don't really care for discrimination discussions too much because people seem to discuss black/white a lot but there are other discrimination targets who have it just as bad or even worse:p

Honestly I'd hate to be a gay muslim in America right now =o"

you forgot about white people. hell, even the government and universities openly discriminates against white people. poor white people have it the worst. and then minority shop/store/restaurant owners are never going to hire a white boy over someone of their race and people look the other way when the entire store has 100% asian employees or black employees, but if an organization has 100% white employees, they're getting reported and fined.

Barak Obama is even campaigning on increasing the discrimination against whites done by the government, and he is more popular because of it.

Re: Are black peope discriminated against?

how can you guerantee anything flint, your have no power what so ever.

NEE NAW NEE NAW

Primo

Re: Are black peope discriminated against?

> They want to attract "pretty" people. I've read this in an article last year.

Yes, i remember Tyra Banks (I think?) doing a set-up where she wore a Fat suit into an American mall and asked for a job application. Hidden cameras catch the darndest thing, and in this case it was more subconcious movements (Not being able to find the application papers, they way they moved and talked etc), instead of someone just shouting 'YOUR FAT, BUGGER OFF'.

> there are other discrimination targets who have it just as bad or even worse
> ...
> Honestly I'd hate to be a gay muslim in America right now =o

Really?

I'd hate to be a gay black female obese muslin who is pregnant. That'd be a pain!

> Computer "Geeks".....

Yes X(, Damit.

Morbo: Morbo can't understand his teleprompter. He forgot how you say that letter that looks like a man with a hat.
Linda: It's a 't'. It goes "tuh".
Morbo: Hello, little man. I will destroy you!!

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=cpP7b2lUxVE

Re: Are black peope discriminated against?

The reason their going to discriminate against race is because certain crimes are mostly commited by Blacks and hispanics such as Theft (hell CVS has anti-theft guards on hair products meant for african americans), illegal drug distribution, gang violence, white people are 3 times more likely to be a murder victim from a hate crime than the other way around.

You look like you've seen a BEAR!!!
If I am to be known for one accomplishment, then let it be that I started the eliminations trend

Re: Are black peope discriminated against?

"...people look the other way when the entire store has 100% asian employees or black employees, but if an organization has 100% white employees, they're getting reported and fined."

Finally someone else is willing to say it.

There will always be discrimination and racism, it's human nature.  I'm not excusing it but let me put it this way, there will be a world without drugs before there is a world without racism, and drugs aren't going anywhere.

There are 10 kinds of people in this world, those who understand binary and those who don't.

Re: Are black peope discriminated against?

African American... There is your problem; Intitutionalised, sanitised, innofensive political correctness and positive discrimination.
The keyword there is discrimination.

If you met Trevor McDonald on a New York street would you call him Black or African American, would you be a racist bigot or a presumptive gimp?

You see, we don't have these problems in the UK, possibly because Political Correctness was introduced to the UK during a time of Anti-Americanism, Anti-Privatisation, and Anti-Anything else that could have been socially relevant as was popular in the 1990's, and so it was roundly rejected for being the stupid idea that it obviously was after a few councils embraced Political Correctness only to find themselves being sued because the people on all of the roadsigns were Black.

Discrimination is discrimination, which inevitably leads to more discrimination, and problems, problems like "Now that we have a 'Black Channel' the White Supremacists are demanding a white channel and we can't come up with a good enough excuse tha won't get the 'Black Channel' taken off the air."

"So, it's defeat for you, is it? Someday I must meet a similar fate..."

Re: Are black peope discriminated against?

I believe that racism will always exist to some extent because its in human nature- something to do with people prefering their own tribe/ethnic group/race

Buddugoliaeth neu Marwolaeth

25 (edited by Gwynedd 18-Jul-2008 23:15:02)

Re: Are black peope discriminated against?

haven't been following the thread, but

DEFINETLY!!!!, most the people who are racist, half the time won't even admit they are, and most the times won't even know they are, it's something some children were brought up with, even if you don't know it a lot of people got it in their roots, and this aint necessarily their fault, and it isn't just with black people

black-brown-yellow-white...any colour they come, it's something we can not be blamed for, it's just something we're brought up with

although what is discrimination on purpose is when someone chooses to discriminate, a quick example, i was going to the states with friends..we were guna go shopping in buffalo, one of my friends was muslim, from pakistan, honestly i prlly looked more scarier than him tongue, but instead we were pulled over to the side, and he was taken inside to be questioned, this man had never been to pakistan, he was born in america, raised in canada, he didn't have any family here anymore, just a student, and when we were pulled over to the side, i got out too, i was under the impression it was all of us, and along with me my other 2 friends got out too, and this officer made all of us sit back in our and only took my paki friends

now that is discrimination on purpose, The two officers chose to discriminate whereas in something like a job interview we might not choose to discrimnate, instead that thought is in our head somewhere, and it effects our decision un-willingly, un-knowingly






----ok sorry, a little more tongue, i read the dressing thing
what the [shoe polish] does dressing have to do with anything?? who made is so wrong to wear baggy clothes?? I'll admit bandanas of a gang or sum [shoe polish] like that is ok to discriminate against, but baggy clothes? are you kidding me??
I used to wear baggy clothes, that part of my life is done, i moved on but there is nothing wrong with that, i wasn't part of a gang, i never shot anyone, i never killed anyone, i never selled crack, that discrimination in itself... you dress like you wanna dress, who made it so ok to wear a buttoned up dress shirt tucked into a pant as high as your chest?? who made it wrong to wear baggy clothes?? You wear what looks good on you, i wore that way back when, now that just looks dumb to me so i wear something different, during the summer some nice cargo shorts, and a nice coloured polo, i was wearin a green one today, and if tomorow i wore a baggy jean down to my ass, and a shirt down to my knees, would i have changed who i am ..over night??

and "dressing from da hood" who in the [shoe polish] said everyone in the hood was a part of a drive by?? -- if being a part of the hood meant killing someone tongue i'd say yeh discriminate againt them, cuz they're all bloody killers, but that aint how it is..