Re: What is a Centrist or a Moderate ?

Zarf: "1: How can you say that a Europe-style socialist system (national health care, welfare system) is the same thing as a much less extreme, yet still not laissez-faire, system (taxes and subsidies on certain goods, or "sin taxes," so to speak)?"

Because I don't view any government as having any moral basis. They are all funded by extortion and ultimately seek to enslave their respective population. The nature of government is that of a law factory; it would be out of character if the government were not, in some manner or capacity, authoring, approving, and enforcing laws; it's why small government will inevitably result in big government. Statism is comparable to paraticism, that is the government exists as a parasite on the most productive members of society. Socialism is the politico-economic philosophy of Statism, no matter which flavor you prefer.

"2: Socialism and capitalism aren't the only two economic systems in existence.  Not by a long shot.  They're just the most publicized systems."

Wrong, they are the only two worth speaking about. Economics ultimately boils down to the question of whether you believe the means of production and distribution should be privately owned and operated, or publicly owned and operated. Either you have private property, or you don't. The rest is methodology. Communism, Marxist-Leninism, Fabian socialism, Stalinism, Fascism, or what have you all produce the same end result: A totalitarian state with total economic authority, aka socialism. It is the trend of every government, and the symptoms in the United States have been appallingly obvious since the late 1800s, and especially since the New Deal.

In reality, capitalism is the only economic theory under which economic calculation is possible, so technically, there is no such thing as the science of economics without capitalism in the first place.

Caution Wake Turbulence

Re: What is a Centrist or a Moderate ?

@ Acolyte

Im in absolute agreement.


I can tolerate a touch of Liberalism in my conservatives.  Im not oblivious to the need of the state to administer my Tax dollars to the affirmed and short-term help for the destitute.  I understand there must be roads and bridges maintained as well, Of course you need a large and cutting edge military to keep our national interests secure.

To run a democratic Republic, you must compromise some of your minor positions to strengthen your important positions.
I understand this as well.

You dont have to lie in bed w/Ted Kennedy, but sometimes you must shake his hand in public.
Problem is, most of these US liberals will shake your arm clear off your body.

Kerry does not support the war by the way.  You dont call US Soldiers the Gestapo of the night when you support a conflict.
He ran against the war, and tried to look like a war hero anti-war protester.   Go figure.


My premise is.........back on topic......there is no such thing as Moderate or Centrist.  There is none.
You are either LEFT or RIGHT.   Liberal or Conservative.

Most in Govt. are Liberals....because in Govt, with there bloated Budgets that expand even larger every year.....comes their power.   Because when they control the budget, they wield the power of position.

I NEVER see a shrinking budget.  Never a politician comes out and says...we did more w/less.
To run a business, is in no comparison to run a Govt.

Leftists and Govt. are inefficient

Come .......joust w/the master.
I'm always Right.   You are just intellectually Left.....behind.
Individual patriot, and a REAGAN Conservative.

Re: What is a Centrist or a Moderate ?

I am a centrist BW, that pretty much proves we exist wink

LORD HELP OREGON

Re: What is a Centrist or a Moderate ?

More later, but I had to ask something...

"I can tolerate a touch of Liberalism in my conservatives.  Im not oblivious to the need of the state to administer my Tax dollars to the affirmed and short-term help for the destitute.  I understand there must be roads and bridges maintained as well, Of course you need a large and cutting edge military to keep our national interests secure."

Acolyte, is Black_Wing a socialist?

Make Eyes Great Again!

The Great Eye is watching you... when there's nothing good on TV...

Re: What is a Centrist or a Moderate ?

conservatives like economic freedoms with less personal freedoms. and liberals like personal freedoms with less economic freedoms. if someone wants more or less freedoms across the board they'd be a moderate.

Re: What is a Centrist or a Moderate ?

BTW this thread grew way faster than I expected.  I have 3 pages of reading to do sad

avogadro,
To my understanding [US] conservatives believe in almost complete freedom both economic and personal.  Capatalism will "magically" sort out the market and the government has no right invading personal privacy.

But liberals desire some of the personal freedoms as the conservatives do. but also want some form of a nanny state with seat belts and some free health care.  And believe that the market is not just enough to completely self regulate.

I'm going to be nicer promise

57 (edited by avogadro 07-Jul-2008 16:03:41)

Re: What is a Centrist or a Moderate ?

conservatives are against gay marriage, the right for women to choose to abort their child, stem cell research, ect. they are also more into cencorship and government programs such as the patriot act which limits personal freedoms.

58 (edited by Acolyte 08-Jul-2008 00:26:00)

Re: What is a Centrist or a Moderate ?

Zarf BeebleBrix: "Acolyte, is Black_Wing a socialist?"

Yes, to an extent; the term "useful idiot" has a lot of relevance in his case.

Caution Wake Turbulence

Re: What is a Centrist or a Moderate ?

Oh  I C.

The FOOL in Acolyte's clothing.

wink

Come .......joust w/the master.
I'm always Right.   You are just intellectually Left.....behind.
Individual patriot, and a REAGAN Conservative.

60 (edited by Zarf BeebleBrix 08-Jul-2008 05:03:51)

Re: What is a Centrist or a Moderate ?

Alright, we're making progress.

Black_Wing, do you believe you are a socialist?

Make Eyes Great Again!

The Great Eye is watching you... when there's nothing good on TV...

Re: What is a Centrist or a Moderate ?

BW: Oh how close you are, I am continously amazed at how close Acolyte is to me, we just both have different means to get to the same place.

Question: The problem of this whole thread is the difference between what a US person sees as a conservative and a liberal. I maintain the issue is that due to the very stong anti-communist witch-hunts, the socialists took on the liberal label and have slowly changed the meanining in the US. The conservatives have re-orintated themselves to fit the new landscape. What escapes me is why the right wingers continue to justify the lefts position? If they are socialist call them socialist (what ever that label actually means.)

Of course this all relates back to the fact that there is no basket in which you can put anyone. Even "left" "right" don't work.

"Sticks and stones may break my bones, but i am Jesus"
"Nothing is worse than a fully prepared fool"

Re: What is a Centrist or a Moderate ?

there is no moderate...u can be a libertarian or an authoritarian if u want to take some poolicies from the right and some from the left.

for example i would be a libertarian because i want more economic freedom and more social freedom.
i support gay marraige...abortion....less cencorship and less programs like patriot act.
i also support less taxes. less government intervention in economic things. i beleive government is innefficient etc...

u can also be authoritarian if u support less economic and less social freedoms.

Re: What is a Centrist or a Moderate ?

Left and right do work just fine.   Fence walkers are just afraid to take a stand....so they believe themselves to be.....Moderate/Centrist/Independent.....etc.

No balls is what it is.....and most of the time, its a leftist.


@ Zarf , getting somewhere ?
Socialist ?

Oh, yea....Im a socialist......and China is Democratic.

Come .......joust w/the master.
I'm always Right.   You are just intellectually Left.....behind.
Individual patriot, and a REAGAN Conservative.

Re: What is a Centrist or a Moderate ?

There is no left, only that which you decide is left...

Acoylte considers you socialist, you consider yourself hard right...what does that say about left/right definitions?

"Sticks and stones may break my bones, but i am Jesus"
"Nothing is worse than a fully prepared fool"

Re: What is a Centrist or a Moderate ?

people disagree with each other on just about everything in our lives, unless you're willing to argue that everything in life is subjective, you dont really have a point.

Re: What is a Centrist or a Moderate ?

BW this is a retarded argument...

If i want economic freedom (rightwing), but i also want the right to have an abortion (leftwing), and if i have a similar crossed opinion on many other issues, wouldnt you sum me up as a centrist? That doesnt mean i dont take a stand, its just not consequently in line with the establishments

LORD HELP OREGON

Re: What is a Centrist or a Moderate ?

It says Acolyte is an Ass, or China is Democratic.

@ Noir...

No.  I wouldnt.

You cant support Economic Freedom, and Socialization of Transportation, Education, Medical System, and the Housing system....along with wealth redistribution administered by the Govt.

That is a Leftist.

Abortion is not a National issue.  Its local and personal.

Come .......joust w/the master.
I'm always Right.   You are just intellectually Left.....behind.
Individual patriot, and a REAGAN Conservative.

Re: What is a Centrist or a Moderate ?

"
Abortion is not a National issue.  Its local and personal."

you dont think the murder of many thousands of humans inside the US could be interpreted as a national issue?

Re: What is a Centrist or a Moderate ?

BW what about someone wanting SOME national programs, but much less than a pure leftwing.. that would also be a centrist

LORD HELP OREGON

Re: What is a Centrist or a Moderate ?

SOME ??

Ok, I'll bite.

What is "Some."


@ Avo
Yea.....Abortion is or never was to be a National Issue.
Roe v. Wade .....and the acceptance of the case, and the OUTRARAGE of the court actually mandating what is or is not accepted was over the top.   Abortion should be left to the local level, never mind even the state level. 

But, it is what it is now.

Come .......joust w/the master.
I'm always Right.   You are just intellectually Left.....behind.
Individual patriot, and a REAGAN Conservative.

71 (edited by DPS 10-Jul-2008 03:29:51)

Re: What is a Centrist or a Moderate ?

>>What is "Some."<<

Well supporting "some" national social programs could include supporting increased funding for federally standardized high quality education while not supporting universal health care or welfare.

For example I support hard punishments for criminal offences, low taxes, and the availability of privatized health care/insurance.  These are generally considered right-wing positions.  I also support public education, the continued existence of universal health care, and that money the government recieves from taxes should go to assist the people of that government by providing a minimal standard of living for it's citizens.  These are generally considered left wing.

On the negative side I disagree with tax cuts for corporations as I feel a governments duty is to it's people not it's businesses, if a business is unable to stand on it's own without the government cutting it a break it deserves to fail I also disagree with government mandates on personal behaviour which include issues in the vein of abortion, gay marriage, drug use etc. I'm a firm believer that if a person takes enjoyment from something as long as no one else is hurt by it they should be free to do it.  Again these are stances typical of the left wing.  On the right side I'm highly opposed to the welfar system as it stands, if social assistance is provided it should be a boost not a crutch and I despise unions with every fibre of my being.

To most people I would be considered a moderate or a centrist depending on how you define the two.  To me a Centrist is someone who regularly takes the middle ground, actively avoiding the extremes of either side.  A Moderate is someone who has a fair balance of left and right wing ideals; so in the same vein as me, some right/left wing policies I like, others I don't.

There are 10 kinds of people in this world, those who understand binary and those who don't.

Re: What is a Centrist or a Moderate ?

>>people disagree with each other on just about everything in our lives, unless you're willing to argue that everything in life is subjective, you dont really have a point.<<

Everything in life IS subjective, as everything that enters any persons life has to be processed/intrepreted by the indivudual and thus becomes subjective. Even more so this relates ideas, such as "left wing" and "right wing."

As shown in this thread, and many many others, BW considers any one who takes any view that is not the same as his extremist view as being socialist/liberal/left wing. He defines these terms himself as being anything opposed to him. However many other people take different views, hence why some people here term themselves moderate, communist or other and yet still fall into BW's left wing basket. The important thing to remember, that despite BW's ranting and inability to forumalte arguments coherently, they are all right (or left) and also that it doesn't matter. In fact it is just about pointless to try and argue the orginal intent of this thread, and DPS is showing, or wil lshow, the useless of trying. BW will just claim he is a leftist no matter what his views on things like taxes or crime are... However aycoltye is our saviour, for he believes that BW is socialist, or somewhat, and nothing BW says or does will change that (well other than completly changing his oppinions and views of how the world should work.)

Of course this works for any other thing in our lives, for everything that we experiance we intrepret and we digest, thus colouring the experiance in our own ways, making it subjective.

This doesn't mean that objective things don't exisit in the universe, jsut that once they are observed by an indivudual they are tainted into the subjective in that persons mind, not outside it.

We are in fact all living in seperate planes of exisistance that occassionally manage to collide and interact.

Of course this is way off topic, well sort of...

"Sticks and stones may break my bones, but i am Jesus"
"Nothing is worse than a fully prepared fool"

Re: What is a Centrist or a Moderate ?

@ DPS.
So, You are a leftist as well.

Again, you believe it is the function of Govt. to mandate and administer wealth distribution.

You Euro-Socialists are way left of us right-wing Americans.


Again, I prove, there is no such thing as a Centrist/Moderate.

Come .......joust w/the master.
I'm always Right.   You are just intellectually Left.....behind.
Individual patriot, and a REAGAN Conservative.

Re: What is a Centrist or a Moderate ?

You dont prove anything BW youre just making your own definition, that anyone that doesnt want anarchy isnt a rightwinger, and is therefor a leftist

LORD HELP OREGON

Re: What is a Centrist or a Moderate ?

"@ DPS.
So, You are a leftist as well.

Again, you believe it is the function of Govt. to mandate and administer wealth distribution."

I don't know where you got the idea about wealth distribution, unless you assumed that's what I meant by no tax breaks for corporations.  I don't see how but if that's the case all I meant by no tax breaks is...well no tax breaks.  Easiest example would be a flat tax where X% of revenue is paid as tax - deductions for EVERYONE.

There are 10 kinds of people in this world, those who understand binary and those who don't.