Topic: Camaar

Has the Creation of the Sentinel Tag and the Increased power of the Wardancer race made playing Camaar obsolete?

I see less and less Camaar players every round

Been dreaming, I've been waiting, To fly with those brave ponies
The Wonderbolts, their daring tricks, Spinning 'round and having kicks
Perform for crowds of thousands, They'll shower us with diamonds
The Wonderbolts will see me right here at the Gala!

Re: Camaar

That's cos we have less and less players, every round! tongue


Nah, jokes aside (or was it -_-) ....i love Camaar, and i'd still play it.  It serves a niche.  But in fams of like 5-7, no room for it.  Bigger sized fams, can support a Camaar for the benefit they bring.

Sentinel Tag has nothing to do with Camaar, imo - though you'd probably argue that you'd want your camaars always small.  I'd welcome Revs and Pax's attacking me, if i was attacking though.

Re: Camaar

Wardancer still lacks the speed, Camaar is still ultimately the best attacker race as if you can claim territory, secure it and fast than that leads to more growth potential later. Many will argue with me about this, but it's really common sense ...

~ Cloud

"I Cannot Awake From This Nightmare As Long As You Exist..."

Re: Camaar

I disagree with Torqez. I still believe having a camaar in any fam is a good idea. Just as Cloud says, the speed bonus makes such a huge difference. Claiming territory early on, being able to hit before lasers is always a must. Later on in the game it'll be tough to fight against a wardancer in let's say a NAP-cancellation war with shares. But anything where shares aren't a part, Camaar is able to do just as well if not even better than most other attacking races. AT LEAST with the new PW setup with less systems and planets.

Re: Camaar

Which part do you disagree with?

Cos I love Camaar, and would still use them.

But if I'm being Eco-minded, if I had a fam of only 5-7 players, I would not use Camaar.  To much of an eco drain.  And although it'll work - I won't be able to have the benefit of being able to strongarm people as much.

(Having said that, in MW a couple rounds back, i was our fams 3rd attacker, and went Camaar.  We made 3 attackers work in a 7 man fam.  But if i was going for only 2 attackers, I'd not want a Camaar.)

Re: Camaar

yup, I agree fam size is also an issue, but with also the current popular strategies it seems that wardancer is extremly over powered compaired to camaar, or camaar is under powered, either way I think its an issue, because although you guys have put in valid arguements about why camaar is still an option, only u guys came to the races defence.

We should get more players input into this, because looking at it, perhaps camaar needs a new look?

Been dreaming, I've been waiting, To fly with those brave ponies
The Wonderbolts, their daring tricks, Spinning 'round and having kicks
Perform for crowds of thousands, They'll shower us with diamonds
The Wonderbolts will see me right here at the Gala!

Re: Camaar

One more arguement Id like to put across is the other pre-set races in comparason to camaar.

Pax - pax started dying out, but with the addition of OH quickly became an essential to ALL fams and with the ability to create rez or gc or even focus on research is pretty customisable, so it fits a larger player base.

Wardancer - again almost died out, but with the new stats and adding warcry makes wardancer literally the best attacking race, and can play well as hc or rez, meaning its played often.

quantum - a totally customisable race, can bank, rez, attack, op and even ss. IMO the best race, but beside that with the super high science bonus this race is worth going regardless of what role u play.

rev - strictly banker race, that needs a rezzer to support it. but not 100% of the time, with the extra income% over custom bankers revs can afford to buy an extra 10% incomes worth of rez of the market for those tight moments.

camaar - is totally amazing for speed and with a good attack bonus is a great attacker race. but totally requires fam assistance to work, it doesnt work as a rezzer race so as such cant rely on market if the rest of the fam is gone and has poor ops to boot.


with the advances of other races mixed with the ever decreasing player base, and the loss of the ability to core another fam due to sentinel, camaar defo needs something new smile

Been dreaming, I've been waiting, To fly with those brave ponies
The Wonderbolts, their daring tricks, Spinning 'round and having kicks
Perform for crowds of thousands, They'll shower us with diamonds
The Wonderbolts will see me right here at the Gala!

8

Re: Camaar

Alundra wrote:

...
We should get more players input into this, because looking at it, perhaps camaar needs a new look?


of kourse it needs a revamp, a lot of players have demanded to add PI for kamaars, and I'm talking about years and years ago.  Then pazz got improved, quantum got improved, while kamaar stayed without the desired op hmm

Re: Camaar

I agree that Wardancers is too strong. The trouble is, when it was slightly weaker, people didn't use it still.  If used properly, it's way too strong.

The real trouble is, people don't know how to use the race to it's strength.

I disagree with this though:

Alundra wrote:

and the loss of the ability to core another fam due to sentinel, camaar defo needs something new smile

I've never looked at Camaar as the race to "core" another fam.  First of all, I hate the strat.  Secondly, Camaar have it's own strength - people just need to learn how to take advantage of it.

I'm not saying I'm against strengthening it - don't get me wrong.  I just see it already as a strong race.  And I see Wardancers as overpowered.  We only changed this "[FEATURE] Wardancers have been improved! +10% Science, +10% Attack, +20% Speed!"

for it to become a race with 0 usage, to now it being popular.  I'd rather make something overpowered for people to start using it, and then tweak as necessary.  Even after the change it wasn't used much.  Only now due the smaller fams, it's becoming the option to use over Camaar, for obvious reasons.

Re: Camaar

Yup Im against coring too, but it was always one of the strats camaar players were used for.

as for adding PI, I agree thats been something thats been needed for a while oo, but everyone kind of got around it.

I dunno, All Ive done here is point out the lack of camaars, If Ive got some details wrong I apologise, but I mean obv u guys know more about it than me smile.  I also dont know how to fix the problem, just totally wanted a brainstorm session to work something out haha.

Been dreaming, I've been waiting, To fly with those brave ponies
The Wonderbolts, their daring tricks, Spinning 'round and having kicks
Perform for crowds of thousands, They'll shower us with diamonds
The Wonderbolts will see me right here at the Gala!

Re: Camaar

Don't get me wrong.  When I reply, I'm not giving answers eitehr.  I don't know what's necessarily right, and just cos I wear the Dev tag, please don't assume I do eitehr.  More than anything, I'm just a player too!

So yea, open for ideas by others too, or something that works.

PS:  When I wasn't a mod or a dev, they tried Camaar with PI as well.  But to give them this, they reduced speed to 150% - which imo was extremely bad.  Luckily they reverted this change!  Speed for Camaar is a real differentiator!  I'm a big lover of Camaar!

Re: Camaar

Most of the better Camaar players don't play anymore. smile

~*✠ ]PW[ Forever ✠*~

Re: Camaar

I think Camaar has just suffered more from the lack of general activity then most families.  They rely a lot more on an active family around them for ops and communication.

On the races in general, I like the idea of the remaining races getting their own op.  Partaxians and Wardancers have their own signature, Revalons Camaar and Quantam have been left out.  Possibly something to replace the lack of pi's would help Camaar?

<KT|Away> I am the Trump of IC

14

Re: Camaar

ya camaar sucked when it had pi i used it that round

15

Re: Camaar

lol but kamaar have IP, so I kannot see the reason why they still kan't do PI  yikes

your agents are able to find a portal in that planet, but for some reason they arent able to find the infra in that planet!  it is ... absurd

Re: Camaar

Camaar is a complimenting race to a Wardancer,  Camaar is a full out attacking race and Wardancers is strong support.  But in smaller families you need to take wardancers.

"It's very quiet on the political arena. I wish someone would stir up some trouble!"

Re: Camaar

yes thats totally right, I always liked to have camaar as my all out fighter with long range capabilities, then with a custom fighting at medium range giving camaar and wardancer support, and with a wardancer being the close to medium range fighter, only going to long range in cancellation wars. but with all the ic changes that balance is lost.

Been dreaming, I've been waiting, To fly with those brave ponies
The Wonderbolts, their daring tricks, Spinning 'round and having kicks
Perform for crowds of thousands, They'll shower us with diamonds
The Wonderbolts will see me right here at the Gala!

Re: Camaar

I don't see that as ic changes.  I see that as a result of smaller fams and a smaller place.

I don't like smaller fams.  I mean, you have a small fam of say 5 players.  Someone cancels a NAP on you, and your 1-2 attackers can't be online - so you auto lose.  Now "that's" absurd, imo.

Trouble is, you can't make bigger fams, cos that means less families to fight and war.  Trust me, it's a tough balance to meet -_- ...anyway, that's a bit off topic, but ...still kinda related!