Re: what if...

You gotta be kidding. Of course we would have to raise taxes. You have any idea how much universal health care would cost. The number are astronomical. Even if only 1/3 of the country were to use it, it would cost billions to trillions. Look at what has happened to social security. The whole program is bankrupt, and yet we want to create another beaurocracy to waste more tax dollars on. Look at the systems in the UK and Canada. They are starting to hold back smokers, the same people who pay the taxes that fund it, hell even their smokes cost a lot to pay for it, are being put in the back of the line because the gov cannot afford to help everyone. I have heard stories on the radio of some people even pulling their own teeth because the wait is too long just to see a dentist. You have thousands of people from countries with universal heath care coming to America to have medical procedures done. You ever wonder why. Because we have a great system. Things should stay the way they are. People don't have a right to free healthcare. The constitution says "you have the right to PURSUE happiness." It does not say "you have the right to happiness." I understand we have some people suffering because they cannot afford healthcare, but why should everyone suffer crappy healthcare just so those few get crappy care too. As sad as it is to say, you have to do what is best for the majority of people, not make everyone suffer because a few are suffering.

"Retreat, hell we just got here!" ~ Captain Lloyd Williams, USMC
"Cmon you sons-of-bitches, do you want to live forever!" ~ GySgt Dan Daley
"We are surrounded? Good, now we can kill the bastards in any direction." ~ Colonel Lewis B. "Chesty" Puller

Re: what if...

should everyone have its own obamaVSmcCain thread?

Re: what if...

too much to read...i'll read up on it later but one thing caught me eye big_smile



> [RPA]Sir SupAll wrote:

> Gladiator, you might as well just marry Obama if all you're going to talk about is Obama in the politics forum.  We don't even have to look at the title anymore - if the author is you, it's going to be about Obama.  I bet that if you were around in 2004, you would've made nothing but Kerry threads.




actually supall i HATED kerry and bush, i hated them both, i didn't vote, wasn't even interested in the election...this is the first time intersted and participating in an election

Re: what if...

But WHERE does universal health care means bad healthcare for everyone?

Universal healthcare is not expensive YES IT IS TRUE!!!

Just no name a few coutries that have universal healthcare and spend less per capita

Australia
Canada
Germany
Japan
France
UK
Sweden

All of this countries have an universal health care system and all of then pay less per capita than US

"but why should everyone suffer crappy healthcare just so those few get crappy care too"

All of the countries above have a less infant mortal rate and a bigger life expectancy

Re: what if...

get them to understand that freelancer and i'll vote you instead of obamarama big_smile

31 (edited by avogadro 07-Jun-2008 14:49:49)

Re: what if...

less infant mortality rate and larger life expectancies doesnt mean better healthcare. if i was in need of life threatening surgery, the best in the world is inside my country's border.

saying you spend less per capita then the US on healthcare isnt saying much. you think that making the US's healthcare completely government funded is going to get rid of all the inefficiencies in out system? its going to do the exact oppositte create many more. one day far in the future i might be pro healthcare for all, but first the inefficiencies need to be caught and taken care of.

Re: what if...

France I KNOW has a better infant mortality rate because live births of terminally ill children aren't counted.  In the USA, if the kids is born alive, even if his lungs aren't fully formed and he dies in a few hours, he's counted towards our infant mortality statistics.   Each country does its own reporting.

UK controls costs by turning people down, right?   Sure we could do that, universal healthcare that works like our veteran's care---Sgt Roy Benevidez won a Medal of Honor in Vietnam, got shot six times and took a bayonet through the hand kicking ass and rescuing a squad, and then spent thirty years trying to get the VA to help him.   

But what always happens, always, when you give Americans a service and figure they'll use it as often as if they'd buy it---they triple their use and the price explodes.   Bush's Prescription Drug benefit is already 2x overbudget and Medicare is 30x what it was projected to cost.

The core joke of Hitchhiker's Guide to the Galaxy is that of course no civilization would develop personal computers with instant remote database recovery, and then waste this technology to find good drinks.
Steve Jobs has ruined this joke.

33 (edited by TheYell 07-Jun-2008 21:09:45)

Re: what if...

Fmods please. New obama threads should be closed untill the last one is from the top of the front page.

[A worthy and logical appeal that is honored in other threads but -I- am not going to follow for the following reasons:

1. Politics is more personal and tied to our self-indentity and such repression of expression would seriously offend 

2. Glad's optimist view of Obama is a substantive opposite to DD's mistrust and will lead to different conversations.

3. We often see two or three pairs arguing at once in the same thread and fewer threads would mean chaotic babble.

4. Fmods like Politics full of politics. Having many facets of the same jewel seems more a blessing than a curse.

5. I'm already a total asshat about flaming and cussing!]

Re: what if...

"France I KNOW has a better infant mortality rate because live births of terminally ill children aren't counted.  In the USA, if the kids is born alive, even if his lungs aren't fully formed and he dies in a few hours, he's counted towards our infant mortality statistics.   Each country does its own reporting."

The data i am refering is given by WHO and there definition is "a live birth as any born human being who demonstrates independent signs of life, including breathing, voluntary muscle movement, or heartbeat."

"UK controls costs by turning people down, right?" link please lol

"less infant mortality rate and larger life expectancies doesnt mean better healthcare. if i was in need of life threatening surgery, the best in the world is inside my country's border."

1- lol inside of your country's border? i do not think that it is true...
2- if less infant mortatilty rate and larger life expectancies do not mean better healthcare what do they mean?

Re: what if...

"but first the inefficiencies need to be caught and taken care of."

The reason why the inefficiencies will not be caught is because people in insurance companies want to make money....

36 (edited by avogadro 07-Jun-2008 16:27:08)

Re: what if...

"
2- if less infant mortatilty rate and larger life expectancies do not mean better healthcare what do they mean?"

they mean nothing by themselves.

Re: what if...

so let me ask you, how can a country achieve a better infant dead rate and an bigger live expectancies? or you don't care about either of them?

Re: what if...

there are alot of ways a better infant death rate or better life expectancy to be achieved for example. if anything is going wrong during the pregnacy or during the birth, if they would immediatly abort the child, regardless of the parent's wish's; it would drastically reduce the infant death rate. if you controlled your population's diet and exercise, and put people on life support for as long as possible when they're near death, you would drastically increase life expectancy. does any of those make the country have better health care? i dont think so.

Re: what if...

Not to mention that the US and Europe each keep a different system of what consitutes an infant death.  The US calculation inherently increases the infant death rate because it factors in more children than the European system.

Make Eyes Great Again!

The Great Eye is watching you... when there's nothing good on TV...

Re: what if...

pffft u guys are impossible tongue

Re: what if...

you're the one who cant answer any points and just attacks us.

42 (edited by windowsME 07-Jun-2008 17:45:39)

Re: what if...

Freelancer - less infant mortality rates means very little, at a guess - that is one issue that would not be denied in a universal health care setting.  That said, it's standard belief that anything the private sector can do, the government can take twice as much money, and twice as much time, to do half as well.  Ideally? Yeah, it'd be great - but this isn't an ideal world, so you do the best you can with what you have.

However, higher life expectancy?  Think about it.  The U.S. Burger and fries staple?  *Raging* obesity as a nation?  Smoking numbers?

Bad news - US has more cars (deaths), more obesity (death), and more smoking (death), per capita than all those countries... healthcare can only do so much for a nation that so happily enjoys killing ourselves.  You're point is fine - but the issue is that you don't want to delve down into something and prove it, you want to prove what you believe :-p


And gladiator - if we were in person, I would ask you about 5 broad questions about obama's policies - i bet you that you wouldn't get a one correct :-p 
Secondarily, gladiator, you hated kerry?  Interesting... since he and obama are dang near the same person :-P

Re: what if...

@avo
don't complain yet, imagine everybody starting their own obama and mcCain thread.

44 (edited by avogadro 07-Jun-2008 17:55:23)

Re: what if...

> windowsME wrote:

> Freelancer - less infant mortality rates means very little, at a guess - that is one issue that would not be denied in a universal health care setting.  That said, it's standard belief that anything the private sector can do, the government can take twice as much money, and twice as much time, to do half as well.  Ideally? Yeah, it'd be great - but this isn't an ideal world, so you do the best you can with what you have.

However, higher life expectancy?  Think about it.  The U.S. Burger and fries staple?  *Raging* obesity as a nation?  Smoking numbers?

Bad news - US has more cars (deaths), more obesity (death), and more smoking (death), per capita than all those countries... healthcare can only do so much for a nation that so happily enjoys killing ourselves.  You're point is fine - but the issue is that you don't want to delve down into something and prove it, you want to prove what you believe :-p


And gladiator - if we were in person, I would ask you about 5 broad questions about obama's policies - i bet you that you wouldn't get a one correct :-p 
Secondarily, gladiator, you hated kerry?  Interesting... since he and obama are dang near the same person :-P




im just lazy and dont feel like doing the research to compare the car deaths in the US to other countries for example. those numbers obviously prove very little because of the so many factors that influence infancy death rates and life expectancy, and i shouldnt have to look up multiple ones for these idiots to realize it.

and barak obama isnt the same as kerry, barak is black, younger, and a better public speaker and thats all the reasons why he is more popular.

45 (edited by Freelancer 07-Jun-2008 19:02:20)

Re: what if...

"if anything is going wrong during the pregnacy or during the birth, if they would immediatly abort the child, regardless of the parent's wish's;"

thats not an explanation for you infant rate to be higher than others since that does not happen in Europe, Canada or Australia

"if you controlled your population's diet and exercise"

that is done by my country. Each family has a family doctor that is responsible for our health, he is payed more if he do no smoke and have no obisity problems. can us non universal healthcare achieve this? no.

"and put people on life support for as long as possible when they're near death, you would drastically increase life expectancy."

lol... all the countries do that in order to push up there life expectancy

"Not to mention that the US and Europe each keep a different system of what consitutes an infant death." if you want to comment on an opinion or post please read the thread ok?

the data that i have is from WHO and there it says "a live birth as any born human being who demonstrates independent signs of life, including breathing, voluntary muscle movement, or heartbeat."

"US has more cars (deaths), more obesity (death), and more smoking (death), per capita than all those countries... healthcare can only do so much for a nation that so happily enjoys killing ourselves."

Read above about what my family doctor does. US system is lack of preveting healthcare

"and i shouldnt have to look up multiple ones for these idiots to realize it. "

1- thanks for calling me and idiot.
2- and in that sentece it shows a normal US citizen thinking.. "I know i am right, why should i waste time to research some data to see if i am really right?"

46 (edited by Gladiator 07-Jun-2008 19:02:06)

Re: what if...

"And gladiator - if we were in person, I would ask you about 5 broad questions about obama's policies - i bet you that you wouldn't get a one correct :-p 
Secondarily, gladiator, you hated kerry?  Interesting... since he and obama are dang near the same person :-P"


shoot away..
and well maybe hate is a bit too strong, but i didn't like him, i go for more than just the policies, it has to be also about who i think can and will deliver, and also obama is the first candidate in a long time who handles things differently, and that's shown through campaign decisions, speeches, and beliefs


and avo, frankly if obama wasn't black he would have a tad bit more supporters,

47 (edited by avogadro 07-Jun-2008 19:03:10)

Re: what if...

"

thats not an explanation for you infant rate to be higher than others since that does not happen in Europe, Canada or Australia"

that was not what you asked me to do

"that is done by my country. Each family has a family doctor that is responsible for our health, he is payed more if he do no smoke and have no obisity problems. can us non universal healthcare achieve this? no."

thats not controlling your diet...

"
Read above about what my family doctor does. US system is lack of preveting healthcare"

everyone knows the dangers of smoking, reckless driving, and obesity; without forcing people to stop, there is no way to stop it. you cant blame it on healthcare.

Re: what if...

> Gladiator wrote:

>
and avo, frankly if obama wasn't black he would have a tad bit more supporters,

if Obama wasnt black, none of us would of heard of him, even me when i've lived in Chicago.

Re: what if...

"that was not what you asked me to do "

lol, actually no, but i thought you would understant it.

"
everyone knows the dangers of smoking, reckless driving, and obesity; without forcing people to stop, there is no way to stop it. you cant blame it on healthcare."

Yes but if a doctor advise you to stop, or gives you a away to crontol your weight it will help your health. And many people will do what your doctor advises you to do, at least my country we do.

"if Obama wasnt black, none of us would of heard of him, even me when i've lived in Chicago."

if mcain was black he wouldn't be runing too.

50 (edited by Zarf BeebleBrix 07-Jun-2008 19:29:35)

Re: what if...

> Freelancer wrote:

> if you want to comment on an opinion or post please read the thread ok?

the data that i have is from WHO and there it says "a live birth as any born human being who demonstrates independent signs of life, including breathing, voluntary muscle movement, or heartbeat."

The WHO is a secondary source, not a primary one, with information based on data given by other nations.

Make Eyes Great Again!

The Great Eye is watching you... when there's nothing good on TV...