1 (edited by RisingDown 15-May-2011 20:09:16)

Topic: Chinese control over Rare Earth Elements

I foresee a scenario in which China becomes the number 1 economy in the world and becomes a joint superpower together with the US. China already has a lot of influence in African and Latin American countries through investments, and will start to compete with the US for cheap recourses. Due to China's economic prosperity and ability to invest in other countries, China will slowely start to win this competition for recourses with the US. Now this wouldn't be as bad since the US has many natural recourses and for the time being is able to compete with China, if it weren't for one thing, one Chinese monopoly:
Control over so-called rare earth elements, or more specifically rare earth minerals (profitable amounts of these elements http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Rare_earth_element). These rare earth elements often possess interesting properties and have subsequently become essential for the production of many modern devices, ranging from lasers, batteries, and magnets, to aerospace components, TV's, camera lenses and various machines used in hospitals such as X-ray machines and PET Scan machines.

"China now produces over 97% of the world's rare earth supply, mostly in Inner Mongolia,[9][10] even though it has only 37% of proven reserves.[11] All of the world's heavy rare earths (such as dysprosium) come from Chinese rare earth sources such as the polymetallic Bayan Obo deposit."

China is in possession of a monopoly when it comes to these elements, producing 97% of them. China has already began regulating exports of these rare earth elements and become more strict. Demand of these elements is rising in China (as well as in the rest of the world) and it is likely that China will make regulations even stricter.

What does this mean for other countries in the world?

"As a result of the increased demand and tightening restrictions on exports of the metals from China, searches for alternative sources in Australia, Brazil, Canada, South Africa, Greenland, and the United States are ongoing.[20] Mines in these countries were closed when China undercut world prices in the 1990s, and it will take a few years to restart production as there are many barriers to entry.[16] One example is the Mountain Pass mine in California, which is projected to reopen in 2011.[10][21] Other significant sites under development outside of China include the Nolans Project in Central Australia, the remote Hoidas Lake project in northern Canada,[22] and the Mount Weld project in Australia.[10][21][23] The Hoidas Lake project has the potential to supply about 10% of the $1 billion of REE consumption that occurs in North America every year.[24] Vietnam signed an agreement in October 2010 to supply Japan with rare earths[25] from its northwestern Lai Ch

Maar doodslaan deed hij niet, want tussen droom en daad,
Staan wetten in de weg en praktische bezwaren,
En ook weemoedigheid, die niemand kan verklaren,
En die des avonds komt, wanneer men slapen gaat.

2 (edited by Godwin's Law 15-May-2011 20:18:53)

Re: Chinese control over Rare Earth Elements

Very interesting!  Link on the subject?

Make Eyes Great Again!

The Great Eye is watching you... when there's nothing good on TV...

3 (edited by RisingDown 15-May-2011 20:52:09)

Re: Chinese control over Rare Earth Elements

All from that wikipedia site.
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Rare_earth_element
This page was last modified on 12 May 2011 at 23:31.

However there was an article on this in one of the most respected Dutch newspapers some time ago. I just recently remembered it because of one of the other threads in these forums tongue.

I'll go see if i can find it in the newspapers' online database.



Found it!

For those able to read Dutch tongue

China keeps rare earth elements for itself:
http://vorige.nrc.nl/economie/article2633252.ece/China_houdt_zeldzame_metalen_voor_zichzelf

China starts to export rare earth elements again:
http://vorige.nrc.nl/economie/article2637082.ece/China_hervat_export_van_zeldzame_metalen


What shocked me at first was how easily China could control this market.




Oh btw the metals are essential to mobile phones and hybrid cars too! Explains Japan's extremely negative reaction to the ban tongue

Maar doodslaan deed hij niet, want tussen droom en daad,
Staan wetten in de weg en praktische bezwaren,
En ook weemoedigheid, die niemand kan verklaren,
En die des avonds komt, wanneer men slapen gaat.

Re: Chinese control over Rare Earth Elements

are there any reports on how much is in south america? i hear theres a lotta rare metals down there that no one is allowed to touch

5 (edited by RisingDown 15-May-2011 20:51:40)

Re: Chinese control over Rare Earth Elements

There are supposed to be reserves of Rare Earth Minerals in Brasil. However I can imagine that country wouldn't allow mining in a lot of places due to environmental issues.

Maar doodslaan deed hij niet, want tussen droom en daad,
Staan wetten in de weg en praktische bezwaren,
En ook weemoedigheid, die niemand kan verklaren,
En die des avonds komt, wanneer men slapen gaat.

6 (edited by RisingDown 15-May-2011 22:23:02)

Re: Chinese control over Rare Earth Elements

Table of distribution of Rare Earth reserves and mine production (http://www.wikinvest.com/wiki/China%27s_Rare_Earth_Dominance). As you can see, China does not own all Rare Earth Oxide Reserves but does account for close to all mine production, it is safe to assume that the same goes for other forms of Rare Earth elements.

Country    Reserves (t REO)    2006 Mine Production (t REO)    2007 Mine Production (t REO)    2009 Mine Production (t REO)
United States    13,000,000    0    0    0
Australia    5,400,000    0    0    0
Brazil    48,000    730    730    650
China    36,000,000    119,000    120,000    120,000
CIS    19,000,000    N/A    N/A    N/A
India    3,100,000    2,700    2,700    2,700
Malaysia    30,000    200    200    380
Other Countries    22,000,000    N/A    N/A    N/A
World Total (rounded)    99,000,000    123,000    124,000    124,000
Source: Mineral Commodities Summary 2010, U.S. Geological Survey (t REO = metric tonnes of rare earth oxide)



Additionally, this is quite interesting:
From the same site, http://www.wikinvest.com/wiki/China%27s_Rare_Earth_Dominance

How is China dominating rare earth supply?


Of late, China has taken a number of steps to cement its monopoly of the global rare earth market. First, in each of the last 3 years, the country has reduced the amount of local rare earth production that can be exported.[4] The total export quota for 2010 is 30,258 tonnes, 40% less than the 50,145 tonnes for 2009.[11] Second, China appears to be forcing manufacturers that use rare earths to move onshore by using export quotas to limit the availability of these materials outside the country.[6]

>>>>> Last, but not least, the country has made moves to buy other rare earth resources around the world. When credit markets collapsed in 2008, government-owned mining companies stepped in to acquire 52% of Lynas Corporation and 25% of Arafura Resources, which plan to open mines in the next few years that would have a combined production equal to 25% of the global rare earth output.[6] <<<<<



As, according to the Newspaper article I read, China's rare earth element mines are supposed to run out in 20 years if they continue mining at this rate, these steps are crucial. Not only do they drive the price of the elements up and allow China to use it as a means to influence politics with, it also prolongs the period over which China can continue mining these elements (obviously).

Maar doodslaan deed hij niet, want tussen droom en daad,
Staan wetten in de weg en praktische bezwaren,
En ook weemoedigheid, die niemand kan verklaren,
En die des avonds komt, wanneer men slapen gaat.

Re: Chinese control over Rare Earth Elements

you guys just wait till Canada proves the shield of the artic comes off their land.

Re: Chinese control over Rare Earth Elements

China can go ahead and use up their rare earth reserves.  In 20 years, when they run close to running out, prices of rare earths will be high enough for them to start a recycling program.  Meanwhile, having revamped its high-tech manufacturing sectors, the West will have a lot of high tech gizmos to sell to the Chinese nouveau-riche, some from with their own rare earth elements that have already been recycled, and, additionally, from the rare earths mined from Western  reserves.

9 (edited by Godwin's Law 26-May-2011 20:46:41)

Re: Chinese control over Rare Earth Elements

I know it's rare, but I think xeno may be right.  (Just joking around, xeno... nothing personal) tongue

The issue isn't one of Chinese monopolization of rare earth metal supplies.  It's an issue of rare earth metal mining and export.  Australia, India, and the US all have significant supplies, but simply are not utilizing them.

This is actually a good thing.  Compare this to the oil market.


The United States has a significant reserve of oil in regions such as Alaska.  Now, if these Alaskan reserves were in a desert in Texas or in a complete wasteland, the well would have been drilled long ago.  Because, quite frankly, barring environmental issues, there really are no short term incentives against drilling for oil when one knows the oil is there... it's an instant moneymaker.

However, its presence in ANWAR creates an additional strain on politicians.


Here's the trick, though: I don't believe ANWAR is untouchable, except by its most ardent supporters.  For example, assume OPEC did cut off oil shipments, and the US had not yet transitioned to an alternative energy source.  Even if the US can purchase oil, the price per barrel would run through the roof.  Or consider a WW2-esque military situation, in which the United States needed to supply a huge war machine (I'm talking total war mobilization, not that Iraq War-level mobilization).  Under those circumstances, I don't believe anyone except the strongest environmental advocates would put the ANWAR environmental preservation over such a prevalent national security threat (remember, I'm talking most extreme circumstance).

So why is this important?  Untapped supplies create mobilization reserves of scarce resources.  Before World War 2, the United States and Japan were able to create a bitter economic war with one another, making the war itself inevitable.  Before Pearl Harbor, the United States reprimanded Japanese expansion by embargoing exports of oil.  At the time, with the US being their primary supplier, the Japanese were forced to take drastic measures to combat this problem, forcing them to speed up expansion in the hopes of either acquiring their own oil reserves or forcing the US to lift its own embargo.

Meanwhile, the US had its own resource shortage.  Of particular note, Japan was able to conquer Malaya from the UK early in the war.  That gave Japan control of 97% of the world's supply of rubber, which was necessary in pretty much every piece of mechanized military hardware.  In recognition of this strategic difficulty, the US had to actually build up a strategic stockpile of rubber, similar to the strategic reserve of oil today.  Meanwhile, the US would be funding development of synthetic rubbers, until the country could obtain independence from foreign imports of rubber (sound familiar?).  In time, synthetic rubbers became more commonplace in the US, and although the rubbers at the time didn't match up to natural rubber, it became adequate enough for the military.

If you look, every country involved in the war inevitably had these resource issues of one type or another.  For example, on the Eastern Front, Germany was within inches of knocking the Soviets out of the war by taking their #1 oil reserve in the Caucus region, which would have taken the Soviet tank and aerial forces out of commission (Hitler botched this up by ordering a redeployment of tanks and manpower for a simultaneous offensive in Stalingrad... and we all know what happened there).  Economics wins wars.  smile

Anyway, those resources in ANWAR that we're talking about act in a very similar fashion.  When oil prices are sitting at $20 a barrel, it's really difficult to make the case that a country needs to drill in the region.  However, as the price steadily rises to $30, $40, and more, advocates can make a much better case in favor of drilling, to the point where it becomes prohibitively more expensive to maintain the environmental refuge.  At some threshold (which could easily never actually manifest), the political opposition to drilling becomes so insurmountable that even its original opponents will be faced with too much opposition to resist a switch of opinions.

It's the same with rare earth metals.  Currently, China is maxing out their reserve to supply to the world.  I am 100% fine with that.  Why?  Because the US has its own strategic reserve of rare earth metals in case China ever decides to use that control to their political advantage.  Meanwhile, China will be using up their reserves during the peacetime period.  They'll make money, yes.  However, for the time being, it's not a strategic resource.  It's kind of the same as complaining that Japan monopolized the video game industry in the 1990's.  Once it actually becomes a political issue, however, production can be kicked up in non-Chinese areas.


But this is definitely an interesting scenario nonetheless.

Make Eyes Great Again!

The Great Eye is watching you... when there's nothing good on TV...

Re: Chinese control over Rare Earth Elements

I agree, Zarf, there isn't really anything to worry about with regards to Chinese control over rare earth elements.