Topic: Political Correctness- agree with it or disagee

Political Correctness- do you agree or disagree with it?

I was in a university class the other day at Swansea University. European Security since 1945 (politics module)

group presentations were on and the question was: Is migration a security threat to Europe.

so there was a Yes group and a No group.

and predictably the No group was all uber-PC lefties talking  about there was no threat, economically migrants were a benefit etc there was no security threat only it was intolerant people that was causing the problems.

In the Q & A part I called them out on it- with reference the risk from Islamic fundementalists. and said that multiculturalism and record migration levels was a security risk because it did not encourage integration and lead to all kinds of problems. I cited several terrorist attacks and numerous plots and attempted attacks as a security risk but they wouldnt hear it.

I went onto say that not all cultures share our values of human rights, free speech and equality & that wife-beating and oppression of women was common in some communities. if they want to live in this country they should integrate.

anyway as you can tell none of this is POLITICALLY CORRECT. the debate soon turned into a shouting match with attempts to paint me as a racist in order to shut down the debate. putting words into my mouth, things which I never said and would never condone.

heck when I mentioned British people as an ethnic group (that is Welsh, English, Scots and N. Irish) was in decline one started saying 'do you mean WHITE people?'  (some of the terrorists were british born but were ethnically not British- ie ethnic welsh, english, scots or n.irish.)

the irony of course was virtually all the loudmouth PC people were in fact English (all middle class who'v never grown up in the real world) and even more it was ironic  that two women standing against my criticism of extremist islam.

Political Correctness- dictatea that rather than get into a reasoned debate over an important issue- that they should shout down any idea that did not fit in with their narrow idealogy.

so I do not agree with PC do you?

Buddugoliaeth neu Marwolaeth

2 (edited by Justinian I 04-Dec-2009 15:20:55)

Re: Political Correctness- agree with it or disagee

I think it is good to be tactful. But I do not agree with multiculturalism. A culture is a result, or adaption to, a population's economic and political circumstances. An agrarian society will have a different culture from an early merchant or industrial society. A society exposed to war will have a different culture from one exposed to peace and trade. Culture has no inherent or aesthetic value. Immigration from a society that is nomadic to a capitalist society is bound to lead to serious adaption issues.

That said, immigration results in the United States have been mixed. In the case of Somalis, for example, integration has been difficult. Multiculturalism has done nothing but shield a primitive culture from adapting to a capitalist one. On the other hand, the Hmong have integrated very well for the most part. The majority of them have adopted Western values, women pursue careers and they have contributed to our economy. A great number of them have provided us with pleasant restaurants and exotic foods. In the case of Somalis, their value of the Koran prevents them from going anywhere economically because they are prohibited from certain economic transactions (taking out a mortgage) and social relations.

I think Multiculturalism can be a good thing, but only under certain conditions. Personally, I think immigration should be limited to cultures with similar economic circumstances or to cultures that seem like they could adapt without serious issues. But in the case of Islam, I think it's clear they can not integrate in to Western societies. Their culture has had a backlash to Western influence, for the most part they do not integrate in Western societies, and their religion predetermines them in to poverty in a Western society. That said, I have no issues with immigration from Europe or Japan. But I do not stand for immigration for the sake of immigration, nor the shielding or celebration of cultural practices that have their origins in primitive economic circumstances.

As for the PC crowd that call you racist... I just love to mock them for being idiots. I will state that racism means you subscribe to a racial taxonomy based on biology, and that I subscribe to no such thing. They are just morons for thinking it is racist to oppose multiculturalism or certain cultural practices.

Re: Political Correctness- agree with it or disagee

they get around the ban on interest by loaning $105K and collecting $105K over thirty years

I love how "you can't be racist and oppose immigration" = "we can't do a damn thing about the guys with masks throwing molotov cocktails"

The core joke of Hitchhiker's Guide to the Galaxy is that of course no civilization would develop personal computers with instant remote database recovery, and then waste this technology to find good drinks.
Steve Jobs has ruined this joke.

Re: Political Correctness- agree with it or disagee

yes but multiculturalism along with political correctness contends that 'all cultures are equal' - clearly cultures thats are sexist, homophobic, anti-free speech etc cannot be considered equal to ones that are not.

Buddugoliaeth neu Marwolaeth

Re: Political Correctness- agree with it or disagee

@ OP

Are you being racist: Yes.
Are you being offensive: Probably.
Is the no group retarded: Yes.

IMHO you have a valid point, but may have
not been conveyed well enough. Yes, they are
right, it is racist...But sensative topics often
are.

Political correctness is making sure statements
arent particularly offensive and that discussion
(and community) can be enjoyed by all.

What they (your no's) are doing is going too far,
PC is overabused these days (incidently just like
feminism...).

I am sKoE
Do you know what the chain of command is here? It's the chain I go get and beat you with to show you who's in command.

6 (edited by Undeath 05-Dec-2009 01:47:21)

Re: Political Correctness- agree with it or disagee

"But in the case of Islam, I think it's clear they can not integrate in to Western societies. Their culture has had a backlash to Western influence, for the most part they do not integrate in Western societies, and their religion predetermines them in to poverty in a Western society. "


And I bed to differ on that completely. Obviously you never got to know a wider variety of people.

If ya'll don't know this about me, but I'm a muslim. And the times I've gotten comments about this is how people go "oooh, I didn't know you were a muslim, you aren't like the other ones then..yada yada..*insert little knowledge they have(which is wrong)*"
Well adapted is thrown in there.

Then they go and spit everything back into my face about my ethnicity and my religion. It's annoying as [a cotton headed ninny muggins] but I try to be tactful about it.


"So you can't drink beer?" "So you can't have sex before marriage?" You try explaining your stance on it every single time over and over and over again. Every set of friends you make that aren't foreiners will comment on this and keep on it as if they want to convert you to atheism or something else. It's something to use a conversation piece when they find their own lives too dull to talk about. Some will even interrupt me and say some more things that would get their faces smashed in if they were talking to other people.


And I know other people, much of my other friends that are of different ethnicity are like me usually act like me, but they lack something. They get upset when someone mentions religion one more [bleepidy  bleep bleepin bleeper bleep bleepitty bleepidy bleep]  time. And I swear to god, one day I'm just gonna snap and butcher em all with a kebab knife and laugh at how silly they look with their guts hanging out.


@op
From what you said, you could have won, but you got stupid.

Not many people know this, but I own the first radio in Springfield. Not much on the air then, just Edison reciting the alphabet over and over. "A" he'd say; then "B." "C" would usually follow...

Re: Political Correctness- agree with it or disagee

I'm a well adjusted individual

Not many people know this, but I own the first radio in Springfield. Not much on the air then, just Edison reciting the alphabet over and over. "A" he'd say; then "B." "C" would usually follow...

Re: Political Correctness- agree with it or disagee

Look on the bright-side. You could be in America where those retards are currently in control of the federal government. Even worse, you could be in California where those idiots are in control of the State government and the Federal government.

No what you said wasn't racist. People don't beat there wife's because they're Turkish or Hindu, they beat them because their culture allows it. Leftards are incapable of thinking for themselves and will spit out garbage without ever listening to an opposing argument. Don't waste your time with them. When they start insulting you and putting words in your mouth it means your opinions are correct. They're too cowardly to concede so they slander.

Rehabilitated IC developer

9 (edited by EmperorHez 05-Dec-2009 00:27:46)

Re: Political Correctness- agree with it or disagee

> Morbo the Annihilator wrote:

> @ OP

Are you being racist: Yes.
Are you being offensive: Probably.
Is the no group retarded: Yes.

IMHO you have a valid point, but may have
not been conveyed well enough. Yes, they are
right, it is racist...But sensative topics often
are.

Political correctness is making sure statements
arent particularly offensive and that discussion
(and community) can be enjoyed by all.

What they (your no's) are doing is going too far,
PC is overabused these days (incidently just like
feminism...).


explain how I am being racist? I have raised concerns that certain cultures have problems which is YES offensive to some and YES it is not politically correct. but how is that racist?

race and culture and not the same, at least not in the oxford dictionary.

Buddugoliaeth neu Marwolaeth

Re: Political Correctness- agree with it or disagee

It's funny, really.  Since being accused colonialists and mercantilists, westerners (especially Brits, French, Germans) have stepped back aghast at the notion and have begun to consider their accusers claims.  They've spent the last 50 years debating it, fighting over such issues as multi-culturalism, equal opportunity and rights for minorities, etc.

Meanwhile, their accusers don't talk of equality of opportunity for minorities in their own countries.  The accusers themselves don't bother to have discussion on multiculturalism or rights for their own minorities.    While the west argues over how to define 'political correctness', those countries which had originally accused the west now commit cultural and physical genocide on their own minorities, and actually take strides to foster racism against minorities and foreigners rather than diminish it.  Racism they use a tool to maintain nationalistic ferver, and you'll never know when you'll have to whip up your population into a frenzy against the 'OTHER'.

Westerners really are entertaining with their talk on political correctness, minority rights, etc.  And they have no idea that they are making fools of themselves.  And their accusers have been ROTFL for 50+ years.

It's hilarious, really.

11 (edited by xeno syndicated 05-Dec-2009 01:09:00)

Re: Political Correctness- agree with it or disagee

Oh and the really just exuberantly laughable thing is that your governments actually give your accusers green cards, citizenship, etc., and allow them the opportunity to get filthy (and I mean really FILTHY) rich, whereupon they re-invest in their countries of origin and then just commit more cultural and physical genocide, not only on minorities in their home countries but on their majority as well, because, ultimately, they don't really care about anything other than earning money for themselves.

And where are your countries' economies at now due to all of these resulting trade deficits?  In debt up to your eye-balls.  Lol.  And your accusers are laughing all the way to the bank.

Re: Political Correctness- agree with it or disagee

> explain how I am being racist? I have raised concerns that certain cultures have
> problems which is YES offensive to some and YES it is not politically correct. but
> how is that racist?
>
> race and culture and not the same, at least not in the oxford dictionary.

I was getting the feeling that your attitude was one that frowned upon the
adoption of other cultures because of their inability to adapt to your cultures
demands (thus, discriminating against another culture because you both
do not share the same beliefs).

(Don't misread this though, i do agree with your original point of having to integrate).

I'll update my vocabular for the future. Oh and the oxford dictionary is not my
bible tongue. I don't really care for the exact meaning of words, only their meaning
in general (that is, i'm not going to argue for an hour the exact definition of
racist and if it includes cultures). Do remember that this is a Swedish forum
on a web-based space conflict game.

I am sKoE
Do you know what the chain of command is here? It's the chain I go get and beat you with to show you who's in command.

13 (edited by Morbo the Annihilator 05-Dec-2009 05:38:07)

Re: Political Correctness- agree with it or disagee

> It's hilarious, really.

I would have used the word sad.


[typo]

I am sKoE
Do you know what the chain of command is here? It's the chain I go get and beat you with to show you who's in command.

14 (edited by xeno syndicated 05-Dec-2009 03:41:40)

Re: Political Correctness- agree with it or disagee

I'm beyond being saddened .  For the sake of one's own sanity, one must learn to laugh at this perpetual folly of humanity.

Re: Political Correctness- agree with it or disagee

The main problem here is, is that people still consider "racism"(I prefer to call it culturalism) to be a bad thing. Which it isn't.

Je maintiendrai

Re: Political Correctness- agree with it or disagee

> xeno syndicated wrote:

> It's funny, really.  Since being accused colonialists and mercantilists, westerners (especially Brits, French, Germans) have stepped back aghast at the notion and have begun to consider their accusers claims.  They've spent the last 50 years debating it, fighting over such issues as multi-culturalism, equal opportunity and rights for minorities, etc.

Meanwhile, their accusers don't talk of equality of opportunity for minorities in their own countries.  The accusers themselves don't bother to have discussion on multiculturalism or rights for their own minorities.    While the west argues over how to define 'political correctness', those countries which had originally accused the west now commit cultural and physical genocide on their own minorities, and actually take strides to foster racism against minorities and foreigners rather than diminish it.  Racism they use a tool to maintain nationalistic ferver, and you'll never know when you'll have to whip up your population into a frenzy against the 'OTHER'.

Westerners really are entertaining with their talk on political correctness, minority rights, etc.  And they have no idea that they are making fools of themselves.  And their accusers have been ROTFL for 50+ years.

It's hilarious, really.


But in the end, inspite of our political correctnes, we still live in luxury whilst the "accusers" wallow in their own filth. So who really has the last laugh?

Je maintiendrai

17 (edited by xeno syndicated 05-Dec-2009 16:24:05)

Re: Political Correctness- agree with it or disagee

"[... ]we still live in luxury whilst the "accusers" wallow in their own filth[...]"

No, they don't.  They either live in luxury amidst the filth of those whom they exploit or live modestly in developed countries.

Re: Political Correctness- agree with it or disagee

> The main problem here is, is that people still consider "racism"(I prefer to call it
> culturalism) to be a bad thing. Which it isn't.

How ISNT is a bad thing?

I am sKoE
Do you know what the chain of command is here? It's the chain I go get and beat you with to show you who's in command.

Re: Political Correctness- agree with it or disagee

racism is judging someone by their skin-colour. thats why it is bad and morally wrong.

Buddugoliaeth neu Marwolaeth

Re: Political Correctness- agree with it or disagee

Racism is not judging someone by their skin color. It is subscribing to a model that humans can be biologically ordered by sub-species, and more importantly that each sub-species has different averages of intelligence, moral reasoning and physical ability etc, because of biology.

It's only imbeciles who use racism to refer to someone who criticizes cultural practices. It's just a way to silence debate and criticism to Multiculturalism and unrestricted immigration.

But criticizing culture is perfectly fine. It makes sense to condemn a culture for human sacrifice. I know that's an extreme example, but if a cultural practice is detrimental or obstructive to productivity and social order, then there is no reason why I can not criticize or condemn it on practical grounds.

Re: Political Correctness- agree with it or disagee

i don't even care to read most of this, i say that let peaceful people be peaceful, and kill the rest, and i believe that it should be a law that everyone carry a gun, that way natural selection can run its course.... as well as legalise drugs across the board... that will kill off most of the idiots that vote for people like george bush.
and if a terrorist kills people, kill his whole family "ALLL OF THEM" that is the only thing they understand.

the world will be a better place for it.

Re: Political Correctness- agree with it or disagee

think about it this way, the less stupid asses we have, the more jobs for those that really want to do something with they're life, and then only one person in the family has to work, and the children grow up with a better understanding of what it takes to be a good citizen.
and offer visectomies to every 18yo, gov paid for, that way we don't have a lot of bastards running arround asking who's they're daddy.

Re: Political Correctness- agree with it or disagee

> It is subscribing to a model that humans can be biologically ordered by sub-species,
> and more importantly that each sub-species has different averages of intelligence,
> moral reasoning and physical ability etc, because of biology.

Nonsense. Racism is the discrimination against a person or people based on race. Its much
more generalised then you say and more often then not those who are racist do some due to
a lack of interaction with another race (I.e. cultural isolation, which is a massive discussion
in itself).

> there is no reason why I can not criticize or
> condemn it on practical grounds

Most practices are exercised within the confines of privacy.

I am sKoE
Do you know what the chain of command is here? It's the chain I go get and beat you with to show you who's in command.

Re: Political Correctness- agree with it or disagee

@BC Cougar

> i say that let peaceful people be peaceful, and kill the rest

So you want to die?

> if a terrorist kills people, kill his whole family "ALLL OF THEM" that is the only thing they understand.

This is absurd. Do you murder the whole family of a murderer? No. Why? Because more
often then not they are (A) Innocent and (B) condemning the attack.

Most suicide bombers are 'tricked' into the act due to a lack of education and are lead like a lamb to believe
that another group of people are inferior.

Ironically your post doesn't seem to differ all that much from a terrorist...

I am sKoE
Do you know what the chain of command is here? It's the chain I go get and beat you with to show you who's in command.

Re: Political Correctness- agree with it or disagee

no they are not, the family is paid and kept by the terrorist for they're son doing it, and most of they're families condone it... you really need to get out to some other countries to have a clue wtf you are talking about.
i have been to 17 countries, 49 states, and in most countries i have been to many Providences so i know the differences.
people that have never been but where they grown up, have a limited view of what the rest of the world is about and how they are.
even here in the US, our own gov promotes racism, just so that we don't see what they are doing to us as a whole.