Topic: Why are rich people rich?

Someone in the 'Why are poor people poor' thread said I had asked the wrong question, and that the question should be 'Why are rich people rich?"  I got to thinking about it and it turns out it is probably a good topic for a thread.

Why are rich people rich?  Personally, I suppose one can boil the answer down to 1.  working hard   2.  being smart   3.  being generous.  In short, overcoming their natural tendencies for laziness, stupidity, and greed.

Re: Why are rich people rich?

The way i look at it, there are millionaires that go bankrupt... and many times the come back from bankruptcy and become even wealthier. So its not just being smart but i think rich people are good at being rich, and then there are those who are just dumb and their money was passed on and they will eventually blow it all by the next generation.

I mean look at Warren Buffet, he didnt start out super rich, he just got a good education but he loved investing and went to a specific college just so he can take an economics course with a certain teacher.... now instead of buying stocks he just buys the whole company lol

Thou Shalt Always Kill

Re: Why are rich people rich?

Why are poor people poor was a good start, but yes perhaps your right to ask why are the rich richly rich.

Consider that for 20 years anyone in the United States who wanted to could earn $100,000 a year, and put $50,000 to $75,000 of that in the bank for a college education, a business, a house, or whatever.

There are multiple ways to do this, but it is hard and grueling work. You won't see family very often doing this, you have to think ahead of needs to get them more cheaply, and you need to keep at it.

If evere there were to many wanting the job rates would have dropped yes, but so much money still would be available.

I consider my effort to earn $150,000 in cash, in hand, as a tour of duty. Now that I am comfortable in the job and the 'dry' season is past, I shall be working hard to get 50k this year in cash (and trade it for Euro's for now, or the Pound).

Effort, sometimes lack of comfort, must be taken to be rich.

My cash can, if all Dem's died and conservatives cut taxes, give me a business earning $1500 a day, a total of 12-15 employees (spread over the week), and operating costs of about $1200 a day... give me a total of $2100 profit per week for no real work by myself.

That figure includes property tax payments but not the huge 40% tax on all businesses here.

This would be the first year dividends, and the next year I would see more 'customers' and would need more staff, give raises to some, and see more net profit.

The positions would be perfect for students, as half the time they will have no work to do, and I won't be a jerk forcing them to be doing make work.

The investment would be about $80,000 to get it built and running.

Payback would be quick of course, so I hazard this would make me 'rich'

There is no way to provide the jobs at 40%, nor 30%. At 25% I could barely do it, but then my personal taxes would push me up to the next bracket (less write offs than trucking) and I would personally lose money even if the business was earning money.

20% means less employees, harder work but I could recoup my losses (investment) in a reasonable time.

Reasonable to me would be as quickly as I could earn that much if I invested via other means.

Am I greedy to think that I could earn money while barely doing anything, after busting my arse real hard?

Everything bad in the economy is now Obama's fault. Every job lost, all the debt, all the lost retirement funds. All Obama. Are you happy now? We all get to blame Obama!
Kemp currently not being responded to until he makes CONCISE posts.
Avogardo and Noir ignored by me for life so people know why I do not respond to them. (Informational)

Re: Why are rich people rich?

Assets

C4|DM
DarkMason
I just told my pilot: "Land it in tha BACK YARD!"
Skee-Skee-SPLAT!!!

Re: Why are rich people rich?

>>My cash can, if all Dem's died and conservatives cut taxes, give me a business earning $1500 a day, a total of 12-15 employees (spread over the week), and operating costs of about $1200 a day... give me a total of $2100 profit per week for no real work by myself. <<

So how many equilivant full time employees? because as far as I see it you would only have 2 equilviant Full time employees if you were paying them any thing close to a 'decent' wage worked on 40 hrs a week work each, and I use the word decent very lightly. Dividing your $1200 costs by 40 gives $30/hr to divide out among employees and other costs. That seems to me, even with low taxes and a different buisness model such that your overheads are low, your employees will be very lowly paid and as such not likely to be very loyal or efficient. Actually dividing your $1200 by your minimum employees count of 12 gives $100 per employee per week, which isn't very much, though will depend on how many hours they have to work each. I do fail to see how you would keep employees, or how the jobs you would be providing would be benificial to the employees, and if you want students you might be trying to hire people who are smarter than you and you might run into issues there. (And I don't mean that as an insult, jsut that it is likely that uni students will be smarter than average and given enough of a sample you are likely to find a person smarter than anyone else in the adult population. law of averages and all...)

As to the taxes, you quite obviously have not put a lot of research into your idea, nor looked at other nations to set up this great money winner. There are always tax loop-holes if you look hard enough. You may need to add additional costs to your start up for a good tax lawyer to find the best way to set it up.


Anyway back to the topic, I refer to my comments in the other thread about poor people. Rich people are rich because they have the oppotunity and drive to gather up more of the scarce resources in some way, and in the extreme cases hold onto them and sell them later at a reduced rate to keep profits up (i.e. the diamond trade.) This isn't an unfair concept, more a zero-sum game. The only real way I can have more in the present is for someone else to have less. It maybe possible for both of us to have more than we have right now in the future, but that requires an increased production of goods, which may mean less resources for future generations.

>>Consider that for 20 years anyone in the United States who wanted to could earn $100,000 a year, and put $50,000 to $75,000 of that in the bank for a college education, a business, a house, or whatever. <<

I would doubt that everyone could of done this. As you said wages would drop if more people put in the work and found these jobs, which would of decreased the total money one would get, thus decreasing it's attractiveness as a idea.

There were still unemployment in the states over that time period and if all these people were able to get these jobs, no matter how hard they were, they would of (or at least 90%-99% would of taken the oppotunity.) The saving 50%-75% of the money might of been hard for some people, given some peoples materalistic americanistic dreams, but a great majority would of saved a resonable amount. So really I think your assumption of laziness is incorrect in the vast majority of cases, and more likely it was a lack of true oppotunity or education about the oppotunities available.

"Sticks and stones may break my bones, but i am Jesus"
"Nothing is worse than a fully prepared fool"

Re: Why are rich people rich?

I got one word for you.  "Greed."

=^o.o^= When I'm cute I can be cute.  And when I'm mean, I can be very very mean.  I'm a cat.  Expect me to be fickle.

Re: Why are rich people rich?

Teh Fool wins! that was a reply to me! muhahahahaha....

And you expect people to stay around for $10/hr? Not that I live in the US so I don't have a great idea how far $10/hr would go.... And I suppose it depends on how many hrs they will work for you.... You will get the quality you pay for, low pay = low quality of workers.... It is something that I have found employers never seem to understand too well.... though my current one does a better job of it as they pay me a resonable salary.

"Sticks and stones may break my bones, but i am Jesus"
"Nothing is worse than a fully prepared fool"

Re: Why are rich people rich?

Einstein, first you assume anyone can make 100k a year. They you say you will pay a salary of 10 an hour.

That basicly mean you assume ppl can work 10k hours a year, divide that by 365 thats 27,4 hours a day.

So either your math is off, your assumptions are off, or as this keeps comming back to, you are dillusional

LORD HELP OREGON

Re: Why are rich people rich?

He assumes that people will work other jobs that pay more and that he can then pay them less.... It is possible that the job(s) he 'earned' $150k in was a theoritical $100k/yr job(s)... he never said he earned that salary, just he earned enough to make $150K at some point, this could of been over the course of 5-10 years for all he tells us, though that would assume he is older than 20. Given he is 'working hard to make $50k this year in cash' it is likely that the $150k took many years to accumulate. He has likely taken the theoritical money he could of made, esp if it was commission or paid per unit made/delivered as opposed to per hour or a salary. So assuming he was on commission, if he was on 10% then he could assume that if he worked 'really hard' he could sell $1,000,000 worth of stuff and make $100,000 that year....

"Sticks and stones may break my bones, but i am Jesus"
"Nothing is worse than a fully prepared fool"

Re: Why are rich people rich?

Fool quit acting an ass.

I am a truck driver. Very few are willing to do this job.

Washing trucks and trailers is an easy job.

Besides the law which requires you to be 21 to drive semi's.

The wage fits the area. It fits the difficulty level. It fits with job levels in the area. It fits Demographics.

Everything bad in the economy is now Obama's fault. Every job lost, all the debt, all the lost retirement funds. All Obama. Are you happy now? We all get to blame Obama!
Kemp currently not being responded to until he makes CONCISE posts.
Avogardo and Noir ignored by me for life so people know why I do not respond to them. (Informational)

Re: Why are rich people rich?

I doubt that very few are willing, but very few think they are capable or know where to start, which is probably more a lack of education about the profession than anything else. Some have no desire to be a truck driver, but one would assume that most of those with no jobs wouldn't complain at being a truck driver if they had more infomation on how to become one...

As for the wage level, it just seems low to me, it maybe perfectly fine for the area, people and job... it's not like i live anywhere near you...


Also good to see you are talking with me....

"Sticks and stones may break my bones, but i am Jesus"
"Nothing is worse than a fully prepared fool"

Re: Why are rich people rich?

The industry advertises frequently yet barely gets enough drivers.

Points to be made;

1) my class had 32 students at start. It ended with 14, and of those 13 were hired (the one guy 'borrowed' my cellphone without permission, harassed me endlessly after I made complaint,  turned half the class against me, the other half for me and was graduated but not hired.)

2) of the 13 hired I have heard six have left.


Your away from home constantly, every government agency see's you as a piggy bank, some states hate you for driving a semi truck, and expenses are higher by far if you're not wise on spending.

The shifts are grueling with 70 hour work weeks, mandated driving times, mandated rest times, and scheduling that can result in six on, ten off, seven on, ten off for weeks at a time.

With usually $200,000 to several million dollars in goods on board criminals see you as a jackpot in high crime cities like Detroit, Chicago, LA, San Fransisco, and the Mexican border.

Yoy typically gain weight, lack home cooked meals, and have no regular doctor.

No drinking, no drugs, and most medicines will ban you from driving, especially if they say 'may make you drowsy'

I could talk about allergies, weather issues, vehicle accidents, bull crap laws and more.

Everything bad in the economy is now Obama's fault. Every job lost, all the debt, all the lost retirement funds. All Obama. Are you happy now? We all get to blame Obama!
Kemp currently not being responded to until he makes CONCISE posts.
Avogardo and Noir ignored by me for life so people know why I do not respond to them. (Informational)

13 (edited by xeno syndicated 08-Apr-2010 09:20:00)

Re: Why are rich people rich?

Key

You say greed is why the rich are rich.  But if you think about it, if you are greedy in your business, whatever that business may be, you don't attract returning customers.  You might get someone to buy your product one time or maybe twice, but eventually the customer catches on to the poor quality of the product, the huge markup, the poor customer service - whatever it is that you sacrificed for increased profit - and they simply won't return.  Your product doesn't get a good brand recognition, and eventually your business fails.  Being generous, however (both with your employees and your customers) ensures overall a better product or service delivered by those employees as well as more returning customers, better brand recognition, etc.

In a word, being generous rather than greedy is why a lot of rich people are rich.

Re: Why are rich people rich?

Perhaps the conflict here is the definition of "greed."  Self-interest, the very concept which results in the creation of profitable business, always needs to exist at some level for someone to even get up and say "I want to make a business so that I can make money."  Xeno and Key seem to be operating at different levels of the understanding of the word...

Make Eyes Great Again!

The Great Eye is watching you... when there's nothing good on TV...

Re: Why are rich people rich?

So now we have a theoretical mamthematician driving a truck bragging aboout how hard it is :S..

The times they are a changing

LORD HELP OREGON

16 (edited by xeno syndicated 08-Apr-2010 10:26:15)

Re: Why are rich people rich?

Greed is one concept.

Self interest is another.

Stop flaming Zarf

Key used the word 'greed', you know, one of the 7 cardinal sins.  It's pretty clear what key meant.

Re: Why are rich people rich?

Greed does not nessarily mean ringing the most out of your customer in one hit, there is the greed to get as much as you can over a long term, whihc is a more intelligent greed.

In any case greed is the reason we get ahead...

"Sticks and stones may break my bones, but i am Jesus"
"Nothing is worse than a fully prepared fool"

Re: Why are rich people rich?

The point is, ladies and gentleman, that greed, for lack of a better word, is good. Greed is right, greed works. Greed clarifies, cuts through, and captures the essence of the evolutionary spirit. Greed, in all of its forms; greed for life, for money, for love, knowledge has marked the upward surge of mankind.

LORD HELP OREGON

Re: Why are rich people rich?

> xeno syndicated wrote:

"> Key

You say greed is why the rich are rich.  But if you think about it, if you are greedy in your business, whatever that business may be, you don't attract returning customers.  You might get someone to buy your product one time or maybe twice, but eventually the customer catches on to the poor quality of the product, the huge markup, the poor customer service - whatever it is that you sacrificed for increased profit - and they simply won't return.  Your product doesn't get a good brand recognition, and eventually your business fails.  Being generous, however (both with your employees and your customers) ensures overall a better product or service delivered by those employees as well as more returning customers, better brand recognition, etc.

In a word, being generous rather than greedy is why a lot of rich people are rich."

Generous?  We have 3 million VACANT HOMES, and 600,000 layed off americans.  GENEROUS is NOT the frack'n word i'd use to describe it.

=^o.o^= When I'm cute I can be cute.  And when I'm mean, I can be very very mean.  I'm a cat.  Expect me to be fickle.

Re: Why are rich people rich?

Xeno:

Why don't you try not being so damn hostile toward anyone who talks to you?  Someone questioning an argument isn't "flaming..."

Make Eyes Great Again!

The Great Eye is watching you... when there's nothing good on TV...

Re: Why are rich people rich?

at noir,

all those things you listed are very few and i mean very few of the positives in an extremely negative society.... so how does that justify that greed is good? Greed causes violence, murder, betrail, broken homes, lying politicians who take advantage of the ignorant, its the cause for ignorance.... i cant see how greed can be good in any way

Thou Shalt Always Kill

Re: Why are rich people rich?

Well sex does the same thing. smile

So does religion.  Bad example.

=^o.o^= When I'm cute I can be cute.  And when I'm mean, I can be very very mean.  I'm a cat.  Expect me to be fickle.

Re: Why are rich people rich?

@Einstein

Most of your post is also true for commercial pilots.

Caution Wake Turbulence

Re: Why are rich people rich?

lol Ukie

Obviously you haven't watched Wall Street.

Destiny is only for those too own to make their fate weak.

~ Geese

Re: Why are rich people rich?

thank you wink

LORD HELP OREGON